4 ms·
It is a black and white issue, the potential harms from vaccines are utterly dwarfed by the harms of not vaccinating your child. Those intelligent an well off
by Nursie 10y ago
It is a black and white issue, the potential harms from vaccines are utterly dwarfed by the harms of not vaccinating your child.
Those intelligent an well off parents are not as intelligent as they think, and are probably suffering from the illusion that their comparative expertise in one field maps easily to their biases in others. The pediatrician is simply irresponsible.
The problem with judging arguments by the tone you perceive to come across is that you are likely to assign negative tone to arguments you are already biased against.
And if you use mercola.com as a source, you are already lost to sense.
- fwn 10y agoThis post is a great example. First claiming absolute authority over other peoples risk tolerance, then degrading the opponents as stupid and after that claiming that a critique on this behaviour is likely caused by bias. Brilliant.
- artursapek 10y agoThese responses came fast and furious, as I expected. It's a good thing I didn't mention that we had a home birth, and breastfed our child!
- Nursie 10y agoWhy? There's nothing wrong with either of those things....
- nommm-nommm 10y agoBreastfeeding is recommended by every medical body for most populations. (Obviously there are some populations where the risks outweigh the benefits) it's about the least controversial thing ever. Home birth only puts your own family's health at risk so very few people will care. Your choice to not vaccinate is a grave danger to the population as a whole so yeah people are gonna get pissed off as hell. Your attitude of "everyone is out to get me" isn't healthy or constructive.
- Nursie 10y agoBut I'm right. I mean, I'd say similar things to flat earthers or chemtrails advocates, and these are absolutely on a level. How else do you respond to something that is blatantly and harmfully dumb? I'm talking in the abstract here. Forget the subject matter of vaccines, what is the appropriate reaction to someone advocating harmful actions based on conspiracy theories?
- fwn 10y agoI think there needs to be a distinction between people who oppose forced/obligated vaccination and people who don't trust current vaccine combinates. Both are probably motivated very different. For example not believing in giving a government enough power to make universal health decisions for toddlers is not exactly comparable to someone insisting that the world is flat. I struggle finding a way to describe the difference, but I'm certain that there is a sphere of moral/political/psychological deviation that needs to be tolerated in a society. But: In general I'd guess that no human is ever convinced by being belittled. Spraying hate (not you personally) and incomprehension only helps the own moral compass, not the cause nor the conversation. edit: words edit: Sorry to those who replied. Hn tells me, I'm "too fast". May take a short while until I can reply again. :(
- artimaeis 10y ago> "not believing in giving a government enough power to make universal health decisions for toddlers is not exactly comparable to someone insisting that the world is flat" You're correct about them not being comparable - people who insist the world is flat won't have any effect on the physical health those around them. As opposed to children who are not vaccinated, who pose a major health risk to all those around them. I hope that my reply doesn't come across as belittling - but there's no safe way to not vaccinate a child. There are, as you've pointed out in other replies, potential risks involved. This is part of life. Trying to shield someone from all risk would be impossible. Vaccines are a necessary risk right alongside letting your children out of your sight. Parents are the sole stewards of their children - and they have every right and reason to be concerned for their safety. But arguing against vaccination because of the side effects which are proven to exist when weighed against the effects of the diseases we vaccinate for seems like you'd have to be drawing an incorrect conclusion.