3 ms·
>I was unclear before -- an exam with an average score of 90 is equally bad as one with an average score of 10. I agree but it's not what I'm advocating for.
by BeetleB 10y ago
>I was unclear before -- an exam with an average score of 90 is equally bad as one with an average score of 10.
I agree but it's not what I'm advocating for.
>Since an uncurved score of 50 is a failing grade, you'd need curving to make that system work.
A curve is inherently about grading relative to one's peers, and I see no reason why it is required. If your test will have an average score of 50, make that a B (or whatever), and perhaps 75 and A. Just do it and fix it to those grades. Do not keep changing the threshold based on your current batch of students.
I think the fundamental differences between the two camps boils down to this question:
Should grades be an absolute measure or a relative measure? I'm strongly in the absolute camp.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> If your test will have an average score of 50, make that a B (or whatever), and perhaps 75 and A. Just do it and _fix_ it to those grades. That's still a form of curving, since you can't know ahead of time on a new test how students will do. E.g. if you arbitrarily fixed it at 50 / 75 and your students do a lot worse than you expected, do you just fail the lot of them? If not, and you move the score thresholds lower, then that's just what curving is. In fact, I had a couple of professors who told us ahead of time that curving could only be used to adjust our scores upward, but never downward, e.g. 70% was passing, but so was 60%, if enough of the class did poorly. Made the students feel much better, since they had a fixed bar to reach. Seems like you'd be satisfied though if the curve used at least ~100 students to calculate so that it didn't change much due to random variation (e.g. if your class is small, aggregate multiple years of data)? Still a form of curving (since you are, at the end of the day, being compared to other students), just with different methodology.