3 ms·
Can I just inject some perspective and say that the question would (should?) have gone something like this?: "So we got 500 million passwords stolen. We're usi
by StavrosK 10y ago
Can I just inject some perspective and say that the question would (should?) have gone something like this?:
"So we got 500 million passwords stolen. We're using bcrypt with an adequate number of rounds, so we only anticipate 1000 of those passwords ever being broken. Should we issue a mass reset?"
It's never black and white, you have to weigh things against each other.
- Bartweiss 10y agoDidn't the breach disclosure say "most" passwords were hashed with bcrypt? Obviously I don't know what everyone else got, but it can't have been better or they'd have said so... I don't mean to detract from your point, good prevention beats reactionary resets. It just raised my eyebrows at the time as a strange weasel word in a claim that users were safe.
- captn3m0 10y agoThe users table would surely contain more things than just usernames and bcrypt-hashed passwords.
- Bartweiss 10y agoSure, and even if the passwords stay secure this is bad for users. But I'm specifically reacting to "hashed passwords (the vast majority with bcrypt)". That's the sort of thing that's usually code for "except the ones which are horribly secured and will be compromised in a week".
- StavrosK 10y agoNow that you mention it, I remember that too. Seems weird, I don't know why you'd have some passwords hashed in other ways. Even if you've migrated, why not migrate everyone at once?