3 ms·
This is a classic, and a good point, and comes up on HN every time we talk about voxels. But I think it's worth considering that: - "Pixel" is an overloaded t
by dahart 10y ago
This is a classic, and a good point, and comes up on HN every time we talk about voxels.
But I think it's worth considering that:
- "Pixel" is an overloaded term. "Pixel" is a little square, sometimes, because common law - it's being used that way.
- This is an article about art, aimed at artists, and if an artist intends to create a blocky image in two or three dimensions, then what they're doing is "correct" regardless of the terminology they use.
- The pictures are really pretty, IMO. I realize some people don't like the block look, but I'm not alone when I say I love it and it's inspiring. The explanations in the article were nicely done.
- The article does cover sampling. Just not filtering.
- When Alvy Ray wrote his paper, the world was made of blurry CRTs. Now we have really crisp digital LCDs everywhere, and more now than then, pixels on the screen are little squares.
- "pixels" even in the days of CRTs have always meant little squares to a lot of people. Video game art benefitted from a little blur, but tons of artists and programmers have always thought of pixels as squares, and for the most part it's a working analogy.
This is why it's okay to call a pixel a little square, and overly rigid to claim it's not one. (And I think Alvy Ray was being funny and making an important point about math and graphics, for a siggraph audience, not pedantic about what words artists are using.)
- fenomas 10y agoI would extend this, and say that all terms are overloaded - so before taking issue with a definition it's always worth considering whether you're arguing that one definition is Wrong and the other is Right (which is reductionist and silly), or arguing that one definition is more useful for the context under discussion (which is often useful).