5 ms·
Part of what Christensen (any relation, pchristensen?) talks about in The Innovator's Dilemma, which covers disruptive technologies ( http://www.squeezedbooks.c
by davidw 17y ago
Part of what Christensen (any relation, pchristensen?) talks about in The Innovator's Dilemma, which covers disruptive technologies ( http://www.squeezedbooks.com/book/show/13/the-innovators-dilemma-the-revolutionary-book-that-will-change-the-way-you-do-business-collins-business-essentials http://www.squeezedbooks.com/book/show/13/the-innovators-dil... ) is that more often than not, incremental improvements are dominated by existing companies, because they're operating in a space they're comfortable, and good, in. This makes it difficult for new companies to compete.
Now, there's a lot to be discussed there, and a huge need for actual statistics, but I think the idea isn't without merit.
- 10ren 17y agoIt makes it difficult for new companies to dominate. The case studies in the innovators dilemma (eg for the disk drive market) show many niche players trailing the leaders. I think the blogger is making the 37signals point that you can have a satisfying, profitable and useful company without dominating. Of course it's thrilling to dominate; just very hard.
- davidw 17y agoI think that, ultimately, it depends a lot on the economics of the business you want to go into. Competing with eBay is probably not an easy thing to do, for instance. Also, you want to be able to do a good job in your niche, not just be a hanger-on fighting for the scraps, knowing that, by and large, the big guys in the market are better.
- lsc 17y agospeaking as someone who gets, ah, the scraps, I can tell you that you must be clearly, objectively, measurably better at /something/ or else you will not get any customers. No scraps, even. When I started out way back when, johncompanies was the leader. I priced competitively, and got three paying customers. On the other hand, you need to understand that there is no need to be better at /everything/ -as the little guy, that's going to be quite difficult. You can thrive on a sub-niche that your competitors may not serve as well as they could. I haven't bought any competitors, but I've seen several go under (one of whom ended up renting space from me to host his personal stuff.) and it seems that the common thread with the ones that went over was that they were 'pretty good' in all areas... they didn't have one or two areas where they were clearly better than the competition.
- acgourley 17y agoRe: statistics, it would be interesting if someone groomed a dataset like crunchbase to start to answer certain questions about tech startups with actual numbers. What is the success rate of companies started in year X that were tagged as "disruptive"? You could answer other questions like the likely hood of various exit types given certain starting conditions. Huge challenge making sure the data is relatively comprehensive, even just for tech, but would be cool.
- pchristensen 17y agoActually, Clayton Christensen is my great-uncle (my father's cousin). I've only met him once though.
- timf 17y agoCool. So as an aside, I think your great-uncle would be your grandfather's brother but this would be your "first cousin once-removed" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:CousinTree.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:CousinTree.svg (and thanks for the opportunity to brush up on that :-), it's confusing)
- pchristensen 17y agoTouche. I thought I had that down but I got sloppy.
- ssp 17y agoChristensen also points out that disruptive technologies often start out the opposite of expensive. They target some low-margin market that is being over-served by existing technology. Then they grow to eat the high-margin competitors from below. There are tons and tons of examples: PCs, low-cost airlines, Linux servers, web applications. Disruptive technologies are often seen as low-end, not-really-good-enough solutions until they suddenly are everywhere and you realize that you have become Digital, US Airways, Sun Microsystems, or Microsoft. The disruptive technology can be cheap or expensive. One expensive thing that is ripe for disruption is mobile bandwidth. Someone with a lot of capital should build a large network of cell towers and then sell the bandwidth to random startups. That would put a stop to 20 cent text messages. (Maybe this will do it: http://www.businessweek.com/idg/2010-03-30/4g-satellite-company-takes-aim-at-cell-carriers.html http://www.businessweek.com/idg/2010-03-30/4g-satellite-comp...) The author of this piece seems to use "disruptive" in the sense of "revolutionary change", but that's not really how Christensen uses it.