7 ms·
If you don't like it, then you're free to go do whatever it is you do like. Right. And as what appears to be the loudest voice in this discussion, it's also my
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
If you don't like it, then you're free to go do whatever it is you do like.
Right. And as what appears to be the loudest voice in this discussion, it's also my prerogative to advocate for what I believe to be a better allocation of resources.
Lets not pretend there is not competition for attention, capital and enthusiasm for vision based projects. That I advocate for one over another - in competition - is exactly what is supposed to happen.So, bring the merits of both and have the conversation.
Just saying yay this thing is credulous and doesn't actually evaluate what are possible futures.
In my case I advocate for Transhumanism and AGI as our solutions to his existential questions and promote those (as does Musk actually but to a lesser extent).
- mikeash 10y agoYou're free to advocate for other things, but most of the critics aren't doing this, they're just shitting all over this idea and then making vague waves in the general direction of other ideas. Further, why so much focus on this particular billionaire, who at least is focusing pretty hard on driving progress even if you don't agree on the precise direction, and ignoring all the ones just wasting it, or being actively counterproductive? That's the part that really drives me nuts. A lot of wealthy people are doing things that are highly questionable or are outright destructive, but they don't get this much criticism.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoFurther, why so much focus on this particular billionaire, who at least is focusing pretty hard on driving progress even if you don't agree on the precise direction, and ignoring all the ones just wasting it, or being actively counterproductive? Because there is nowhere to engage with them or around their capital allocation specifically? Also because the problem set they are trying to solve is not as ambitious. Remember the problem set for this Mars project is basically "Saving Humanity from Extinction." You see similar conversations come up when large scale renewable projects are invested in - wherein people shout about how people should be investing in fusion or Thorium etc... Also, if someone comes out and says "We're investing in Docker" and the response is "You should be investing in AI instead!!" it just makes you look like a crank - largely because they are different value investments.
- mikeash 10y agoMy point is basically that it just makes you look like a crank regardless of whether the subject is Docker or Mars. Sure, people do this stuff all the time. And it's ridiculous, and I can't understand why people are doing it here or why you're defending it. You're saying that if people are highly ambitious and trying to do some good, that makes them more of a target. And furthermore, you seem to be embracing that. I agree with the former, but strongly reject the latter.
- mintplant 10y ago> Further, why so much focus on this particular billionaire, Personally, I'm worried by the fact that it's a billionaire driving this, nevermind which one in particular. If and when SpaceX colonizes Mars, what sort of life will the people up there live? Will it be a Musk dictatorship? A corporate fiefdom? Rich people remaking society in their own image wasn't exactly the space dream I grew up with.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's not like NASA or anyone else is going to make it happen anytime soon if this weren't happening. If anyone else wants to take a shot at Mars, they're more than welcome to. Even long after SpaceX's plans come to fruition (assuming they ever do), Mars is a big place and there will be plenty of room for other organizations to do their own thing.
- the_watcher 10y agoYour concern is that a billionaire is driving a private project that will cost billions of dollars?
- ghurtado 10y ago> Rich people remaking society in their own image wasn't exactly the space dream I grew up with. It wasn't the "earth dream" I grew up with either, and yet, here we are.
- __derek__ 10y agoInternational law (i.e. the Outer Space Treaty[1]) does not cease to apply in the event that it's a corporation that does the exploring. [1]: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty_of_1967#Article_VII https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Outer_Space_Treaty_of_1967#Ar...
- JabavuAdams 10y agoAny of these is possible, but the character of the founders really does matter.
- mzw_mzw 10y ago
- BjoernKW 10y ago> That's the part that really drives me nuts. A lot of wealthy people are doing things that are highly questionable or are outright destructive, but they don't get this much criticism. For one part, I think many people just expect wealthy people to do questionable and outright destructive things. If there's someone that doesn't fit these expectations he or she shatters that worldview because wealthy people can't at the same time be good people, too, can they? This has a lot to do with a warped sense of equality and equity: People who aren't so well-off don't get to have these opportunities to change the world in one way or another so the ones who are in that worldview shouldn't get to embark on positive endeavours either, so everyone is equally miserable. The fallacy with that of course is that with everyone feeling equally miserable everyone's worse-off whereas if people - wealthy or not - make the most out of the deck they've been dealt everybody (or at least society as a whole) will profit.
- bborud 10y agoThe funny thing about Elon Musk is that he actually accomplishes stuff. Which is not the norm among vision-driven people. I regularly get approached by vision-driven projects, to help them make something concrete, and the vast majority of them will accomplish nothing because the people on them are not doers and they don't understand practical matters. Many, many people do not understand the difference between dreaming and doing. And many people will happily waste their entire life dreaming about things and then getting bitter when someone else doesn't realize it for dem and give them the credit. I'm not going to name names, but I had a discussion with a fairly known "visionary" who has been trying to claim credit for something which he did not do. Simply because he fucked around with an idea without actually making any progress on it for _decades_. All he did was to make it ever more complex and unattainable by adding useless shit to it. Then when someone actually managed to strip the idea down to something that could be realized he first shit all over it and then tried to claim credit for it once it became successful. Yet he wanted everyone to recognize him for his "contributions". I generally don't give a shit about what people who do nothing think. To me, they do not count. Elon Musk does stuff. His critics don't. Let's start there.
- lloeki 10y ago> better allocation of resources Let me argue that allocation of resources as a zero-sum game is a deeply flawed view of the situation. There is competition, but this is not a bucket-for-bucket transfer and given the figures displayed here as well as ballpark estimations, there is more than largely room for all of those to develop simultaneously. As mikeash points out, there is an untapped audience as well as boatloads of resources going down the sink that totally dwarf the resources put in any of those endeavours (and this extends way past "wasteful" billionaires)
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThe problem is that while what you say is true over a long period, it's not true in the time period necessary to make progress work. This is especially biting when you go out to raise money - there is a limited pool of money out there that is looking to be allocated. Sure, some small changes open up small amounts - such as the introduction of crowdfunding - but generally speaking there are more companies seeking funds than there are funds seeking investment. Said another way the pie grows too slowly to consider the market anything other than zero-sum over the window of time that a venture has.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- savagej 10y agoJust pass a few laws. Outlaw the First Amendment, so people can't spread these dangerous ideas. Put people like yourself in charge of 1st world nations. Then confiscate the wealth of anyone who attempts travel to Mars. Anyone who attempts this dangerous idea in secret would be locked up, of course. I'm sure you have it all figured out.
- lazyjones 10y ago> it's also my prerogative to advocate for what I believe to be a better allocation of resources. Honest question, not trying to be rude: what makes you believe you have a better idea of what a good allocation of resources (and Elon Musk's / SpaceX's skills) would be? If you're so smart and good at allocating resources, what prevents you from pursuing that other project instead of demanding from other people to follow your lead?
- AndrewKemendo 10y agowhat makes you believe you have a better idea of what a good allocation of resources (and Elon Musk's / SpaceX's skills) would be? Same reason as anyone else I suppose. Not really sure how to answer that without sounding like a douche. If you're so smart and good at allocating resources, what prevents you from pursuing that other project instead of demanding from other people to follow your lead? I mean that's exactly what I'm doing...
- lmm 10y ago> Honest question, not trying to be rude: what makes you believe you have a better idea of what a good allocation of resources (and Elon Musk's / SpaceX's skills) would be? We all advocate for what we believe, advance our best arguments, and collectively reach conclusions. That's how discussion is supposed to work, no? Or are we supposed to pick the smartest person in the room and then ignore everyone else?