4 ms·
It is pretty close to eugenics, whose ethical problems are I think well-acknowledged now. (And it's worth noting that these ethical problems were not acknowledg
by geofft 10y ago
It is pretty close to eugenics, whose ethical problems are I think well-acknowledged now. (And it's worth noting that these ethical problems were not acknowledged in the US in the early 20th century, and a very large number of reasonable people were excited about eugenics.)
- int_19h 10y agoEugenics is different in that it was an attempt to make these decisions in a centralized fashion, and imposed at the entire population. Basically, "we know better" with respect to reproductive freedom. In that sense, laws regulating how parents may or may not change the genome of their kids are closer to the concept of eugenics than laissez-faire. Note, I'm not saying that laissez-faire here is the right approach, necessarily. Some amount of regulation is necessary, at least, to prevent parents from knowingly imposing debilitating choices on their children. Which, again, is very reminiscent of eugenics, actually, except that they got carried away with what exactly was supposed to be undesirable, and eventually made it into all-encompassing social engineering approach.
- geofft 10y agoOnce the option for designer babies exists, wouldn't the invisible hand of the market start trying to impose this in a centralized fashion? Medical insurance (legitimately, IMO) tries to encourage you towards preventive care over reactive care. Once this technology is freely available, wouldn't insurance companies be more inclined to pay to make your baby a designer baby instead of paying for certain types of pediatric care that designer babies don't need?
- int_19h 10y agoIt might be. Although if it targets genuine medical conditions, which I'd imagine what they would actually care about in terms of insurance payouts, I'm not sure it's necessarily a bad thing. Either way, this is yet another reason as to why healthcare should be publicly funded (or at least have a public insurance option)...