2 ms·
If it was closed-source, we would assume it had lots of issues until reviewed by a qualified, third party that we trust saying otherwise who also gives us signe
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
If it was closed-source, we would assume it had lots of issues until reviewed by a qualified, third party that we trust saying otherwise who also gives us signed hash for binary that was reviewed. The way it's been done in proprietary evaluations a long time. It would be done more if companies were actually interested in a real evaluation instead of a stamp that knocks out their liability. ;)
Under DOD's TCSEC criteria, the high-assurance systems (A1-class) also had to be delivered in source form to paying customers with evaluation evidence. They can check hashes/signatures, check the evaluation evidence themselves, and build it on site. So, vendors got paid large sums of money to develop the products, independent evaluation ensured you got some pentesting, and you could inspect the source yourself. My modification to the scheme involved evaluators with hacking background in mutually-suspicious countries working side-by-side with developers every step of the way.
Traditional open-source development is weak against all of these given there's usually a lack of qualified expertise or just people willing to dig into it. Just open-sourcing something gets people almost nothing in security. Has to be reviewed.
- nkassis 10y agoIn the case of edge, Microsoft could do both. Not sure where the drawback would be.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI think the main thing is that Microsoft makes billions from what lock-in remains in their tech. They are probably very afraid that open-source would've made things like OpenOffice happen for all their locked-in tech at great development speed and compatibility. Plus on better platforms that Microsoft doesn't sell. Maybe even ReactOS greatly accelerated by the availability of source. ;) That's my theory anyway. They share source with some but highly selective with plenty restrictions.
- makomk 10y agoSome of the recent proposed international trade treaties would forbid governments from requiring companies to supply source code for their software, if I recall correctly.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoNo doubt inspired by bottom line and SIGINT concerns. In that case, it can be voluntary as a differentiator.