3 ms·
Why not simply model Phone as a relation: Knows(John, Phone(Mary, X)) (and so Knows ⊆ Person × (Person × Number))? After all, Knows(John, Phone(Mary)) doe
by pron 10y ago
Why not simply model Phone as a relation:
Knows(John, Phone(Mary, X))
(and so Knows ⊆ Person × (Person × Number))? After all, Knows(John, Phone(Mary)) doesn't really model the problem at all, as Phone(Mary) is just some integer, and that formalization simply denotes a relation between John and some integer, while "John knows Mary's phone number" really means that John knows that Mary and the number X are related by the Phone relation.
- lisper 10y ago> Phone(Mary) is just some integer Exactly right. But the problem is that if Phone(Mary) is a function that returns an integer, then what is Phone(Mary, X)? If you're going to be syntactically consistent it must be a function of two arguments that returns a value. It's probably a predicate that returns true or false. So Phone(Mary, X) == True IFF X is Mary's phone number. But now you have the same problem of distinguishing Phone(Mary, X) and "Phone(Mary, X)" as you did Phone(Mary) and "Phone(Mary)". It's even worse now because extensionally (i.e. where functions applied to arguments are equivalent to their values) you can now substitute any true statement for Phone(Mary, X) and obtain another true statement under the law of substitution of equals.