3 ms·
Fewest vulnerabilities: I suspect that Chrome and Firefox being open source is a factor here. Thus it seems possible to me that they actually have fewer vulnera
by chrismorgan 10y ago
Fewest vulnerabilities: I suspect that Chrome and Firefox being open source is a factor here. Thus it seems possible to me that they actually have fewer vulnerabilities than Edge—Edge’s just haven’t been found yet.
This is pure speculation on my part; I have no evidence nor any investigation, deep or otherwise.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"Edge’s just haven’t been found yet." Haven't been introduced and haven't been found. It's both. Microsoft's SDL has dramatically reduced number of 0-days in their products. I speculate that eliminating many common vulnerability classes also eliminates a lot of the low-hanging fruit that's easiest to spot in the binaries by reverse engineers. They have potential to raise the security even higher if they apply MS Research's tools like VCC or Dafny. I don't even know what Edge is written in, though.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoYou're kind of talking out of your ass here, fyi. They have been introduced and they have been found. Don't underestimate Google's resources on chrome. Especially considering that many Google security folks were previously at MS.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIm not sure what comment you read as I mentioned they both have 0-days and that number of them dropped sharply due to SDL. The numbers available prove both. Even more true given attackers are focusing on common applications more than Windows itself. That's because they're easier to attack than Windows code.
- ThinkBeat 10y agoChrome and Firefox has a much larger userbase than Edge has. (As of now). As Edge matures and its userbase grows we will have a chance to see how it measures up :)
- WorldMaker 10y agoEdge's JS engine (Chakra) has had the majority of itself open sourced (ChakraCore). Given how central the JS engine is to overall browser security, I wonder if that changes your suspicions at least a bit?
- timmeyh 10y agoAlso keep in mind that almost no-one is using edge: 4 till 5% browser market share (depending on the source used for such data). Whereas Chrome has a 25-35% market share (again, depending on source). It's just plain obvious that people don't want to put in a lot of effort to find a vulnerability as their target audience/ ROI is only so little...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]