3 ms·
How can the CA be _more_ trustworthy as to whether the other party is really Bank of America... than Bank of America itself is? I don't understand your argumen
by jrochkind1 10y ago
How can the CA be _more_ trustworthy as to whether the other party is really Bank of America... than Bank of America itself is?
I don't understand your argument, and I think it's a novel interpretation of the CA infrastruture, I think whatever threats you are considering (that Bank of America would intentionally lie about what website is a Bank of America website?) is not something the CA infrastructure was designed to protect against or is capable of protecting against.
If authorized Bank of America staff is committed to claiming some website is Bank of America, they can get it trusted as Bank of America by a third-party CA too, can't they? I think by definition any website that authorized Bank of America agents claim is a Bank of America website, _is_ a Bank of America website. That's all it means to be "really" a BoA website, to be a website BoA intentionally meant to represent BoA.
I don't think the CA infrastructure can possibly defend against authorized Bank of America agents claiming a website is a BoA website when you think they were wrong to claim that. The CA infrastructure is meant to guarantee that the website was intentionally authorized by Bank of America to be a Bank of America website -- that's it. It doesn't even always do that securely because of flaws, but it never does any more than that.
Am I missing something?