6 ms·
This would make a lot more sense than a tech company buying Twitter. Twitter is, more than anything, a media company. It's a bit unfair they're compared to tec
by chatmasta 10y ago
This would make a lot more sense than a tech company buying Twitter.
Twitter is, more than anything, a media company. It's a bit unfair they're compared to tech companies in terms of performance.
Twitter is a cultural phenomenon more than a product. That's why I'm always skeptical of people questioning its long term success. Unless another platform emerges to replace it, its cultural momentum should be enough to sustain its presence, even without profitability.
Maybe Twitter will never be individually profitable, but it has enough cultural power for a large media company to justify subsidizing its costs with profits from the overall income of a media empire.
As such, Twitter seems better off as a unit of a large media company like Disney rather than a calculated profit center like Google or Facebook. Its synergy with other products can make it a sustainable investment for a media company.
Disney was one of the first companies to popularize Twitter, as ESPN and ABC contributed to its early growth by bringing athlete and celebrity tweets into the mainstream. The Disney media empire benefits from this synergy with Twitter. It therefore makes sense for Disney to roll Twitter into its media portfolio.
- wyldfire 10y ago> Maybe Twitter will never be individually profitable Stupid question, sorry -- what's their business model? Paid commercial accounts? I don't look at twitter often but I don't think I've ever seen ads.
- onewland 10y agoThey put sponsored tweets (tailored to individuals) in the timeline.
- empath75 10y agoThey're going to get murdered in the press for publishing hate speech and neo nazis and terrorists.
- Spivak 10y agoAnd then murdered in the press for censorship if they try to do something about it. How journalists, bloggers, and other professional outrage generators feel about Twitter's policies isn't a great metric for the current or future success of a platform.
- cableshaft 10y agoProfessional outrage generators is a great term for it. There's way too many people online whose job is essentially this right now.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jcoffland 10y ago> Twitter is, more than anything, a media company. It's a bit unfair they're compared to tech companies in terms of performance. How is Twitter any different in this respect than FB?
- gdulli 10y agoOn Facebook you follow your friends and family and acquaintances, your community is predetermined. It's not content, it's chatter. On Twitter you follow people you want to follow, who produce content you find interesting. There are subcultures. There's personality. There's less social pressure to follow your aunt, uncle, or distant co-workers from 2 jobs ago. The people you don't want to follow tend not to be even on Twitter, the people who just want to chatter are happy on Facebook. The smaller social graph of Twitter is a feature (from the users' point of view) because the ratio of signal to noise is higher. So it is more about content. If you use Twitter the way you use Facebook, and make it about your real-life social graph, you'll likely find it uncompelling.
- mseebach 10y agoI could see how your "interest-graph" (continually updated, no less) is more valuable from a marketing perspective than your "real-life social graph". There's more marketing-signal in knowing you're a techie than who your aunt is.
- f_allwein 10y agoOk, but what exactly would Disney do with Twitter? How is it going to help them conduct their business?
- vinceguidry 10y agoEven if all it does for them is add another marketing channel for Disney content, it could be well worth its price.
- Mahn 10y agoThe only thing I can picture is them "exploiting" Twitter to push new films and releases to their will, but the consequences of this would be disastrous for the future of Twitter. Honestly, at this point Twitter would be better off as a non-profit ala Wikipedia, but I guess it's too late for that.
- logfromblammo 10y agoEvery Disney media property cross-promotes every other Disney property. If Disney buys Twitter, every star in their stable will likely be required to tweet out a certain amount of content every day. Freshface McSongbird and Heartthrob McCleancut will tweet about going to see Rogue One in theaters, for instance.
- heroprotagonist 10y agoIf that's all they want from it, then they don't need to buy Twitter to gain the ability. Freshface McSongbird could be required to tweet without Disney having any ownership stake in the company. They could exploit the 'promoted tweets' more, but you could buy an awful lot of promoted tweets for less than 20bn.
- gumby 10y agoDisney is a conglomerate that doesn't just make movies and theme parks. They also own the ABC television network and ESPN (and I'm sure others). I assume if this rumor is true and not a stalking horse that they figure owning another channel to end users is more valuable than just sending their content through it. Since they can already use Twitter for free, I assume it's all about the analytics. But this is all a guess. I have to say that the Disney execs I've met have all been very smart and good at execution.
- bogomipz 10y ago"Twitter is, more than anything, a media company. It's a bit unfair they're compared to tech companies in terms of performance" The company has never made a profit. How does comparing them to other media companies instead of other tech companies change that?