6 ms·
Disney Considers Offer for Twitter
- Grue3 10y agoMight as well say goodbye to all NSFW content then.
- pjc50 10y agoAnd the political content. You might have a ""Twitter Revolution"" but you'll never have a Disney one. On the other hand, something might finally be done about the harassment of the few remaining users.
- chatmasta 10y agoDisney owns ABC. I would hardly call it an apolitical company.
- knowtheory 10y agoThis is unlikely as demonstrated by things like Disney's stake in Vice
- askafriend 10y agoand all the album leak download links!
- chatmasta 10y agoThis would make a lot more sense than a tech company buying Twitter. Twitter is, more than anything, a media company. It's a bit unfair they're compared to tech companies in terms of performance. Twitter is a cultural phenomenon more than a product. That's why I'm always skeptical of people questioning its long term success. Unless another platform emerges to replace it, its cultural momentum should be enough to sustain its presence, even without profitability. Maybe Twitter will never be individually profitable, but it has enough cultural power for a large media company to justify subsidizing its costs with profits from the overall income of a media empire. As such, Twitter seems better off as a unit of a large media company like Disney rather than a calculated profit center like Google or Facebook. Its synergy with other products can make it a sustainable investment for a media company. Disney was one of the first companies to popularize Twitter, as ESPN and ABC contributed to its early growth by bringing athlete and celebrity tweets into the mainstream. The Disney media empire benefits from this synergy with Twitter. It therefore makes sense for Disney to roll Twitter into its media portfolio.
- wyldfire 10y ago> Maybe Twitter will never be individually profitable Stupid question, sorry -- what's their business model? Paid commercial accounts? I don't look at twitter often but I don't think I've ever seen ads.
- onewland 10y agoThey put sponsored tweets (tailored to individuals) in the timeline.
- empath75 10y agoThey're going to get murdered in the press for publishing hate speech and neo nazis and terrorists.
- Spivak 10y agoAnd then murdered in the press for censorship if they try to do something about it. How journalists, bloggers, and other professional outrage generators feel about Twitter's policies isn't a great metric for the current or future success of a platform.
- cableshaft 10y agoProfessional outrage generators is a great term for it. There's way too many people online whose job is essentially this right now.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jcoffland 10y ago> Twitter is, more than anything, a media company. It's a bit unfair they're compared to tech companies in terms of performance. How is Twitter any different in this respect than FB?
- 10y ago
- mkagenius 10y agoWhy doesn't facebook buy Twitter? It aligns well with its mission, also helps in establishing monopoly.
- dageshi 10y agoThe last thing Facebook wants to do is appear to be a monopoly, if it bought Twitter it would pretty much own the entire social space so it'll never do it.
- jfoster 10y agoThey would probably attract unwanted regulatory interest if they even twitched in that direction.
- askafriend 10y agoI just don't think Facebook sees $10-20B in value that it couldn't build itself. Facebook's been building real-time Twitter-like features into it's core product for a while now. They're features that the general public will actually see/use compared to Twitter's niche active userbase. For Disney/Google, it's $10-20B in value that they CAN'T capture themselves and don't have the DNA to do so, so it's far more valuable for them at this price. If Twitter were $5B, then I have no doubt Facebook would try to snap (no pun intended) them up.
- choward 10y agoYou don't purchase a software company purely for its product. You also purchase the users and software engineers.
- askafriend 10y agoI agree, and I think the users/team would be more beneficial to Disney and Google than Facebook (which already has the DNA to build great social products).
- mc32 10y agoI just hope this does not go the way of the go.com acquisition. Almost as good as the AOL-Netscape tie-up.
- AimHere 10y agoTwitter isn't exactly profitable at the moment (quite the reverse) and it's pushed past it's coolest-kid-on-the-block stage of the internet platform lifecycle. I dunno about anybody else, but this gives me Myspace flashbacks - an entrepreneur offloads his slightly over-the-hill social media platform to a passing old media dinosaur in exchange for a ton of money, and leaves them holding the bag throughout it's inevitable decline. With Dorsey's leverage as a Disney board member, Twitter might be able to pressure or convince the company into doing things it wouldn't otherwise do, if it was thinking straight. Maybe I'm wrong, of course, and Disney does have good plans for Twitter, but there's a little alarm bell ringing here.
- influx 10y agoIt would be trivial to make twitter profitable by laying off most of the engineering team in San Francisco, and moving the ops teams to the folks who run ESPN web properties. Just keep the lights on, maintain the software and it would mint money.
- jerf 10y agoOnly for a brief time. As Twitter stood still and the rest of the ecosystem moves on (and the biological metaphor is fairly apt here), all the other things in the ecosystem would figure out how to eat Twitter's lunch. Twitter's value (such as you may think it is) would depreciate fairly quickly in that scenario. It's not a mint forever. It probably wouldn't even be a mint on the timescale that, say, the Marvel cinematic universe has been and will be a mint.
- exstudent2 10y agoTwitter has been standing still for a really long time.
- jerf 10y agoOnly on the outside. Let it also stand still on the inside and the results will be different.
- shmerl 10y agoI wonder if Disney would kill Twitter's patents disarmament policy if they buy them.
- ldayley 10y agoKeep in mind that Jack Dorsey is on the Board of Directors of Disney (whih is mentioned in the article for those of you who tl;dr)
- knowtheory 10y agoDisney is a machine that monetizes fandom, and Twitter is pretty good about fan communities (modulo the conversation about abuse). The conversation about whether twitter will be successful at streaming live content is interesting, but probably just one of those things that demonstrates whether or not they have _further_ growth potential into other spaces. Twitter is already where lots of people go to talk about sporting events, news as it's happening, shared experiences like TV watching, and so on. To the extent to which Disney can get access to users in the throes of emotion or facilitate deeper investment in their properties is probably useful for Disney on its face, even before anything more is built on top of or into twitter.
- jerf 10y ago"Disney is a machine that monetizes fandom, and Twitter is pretty good about fan communities (modulo the conversation about abuse)." I'd submit one of the ways in which Twitter is "pretty good" about fan communities, by being relatively permissive about IP they don't particularly care about, is precisely a way in which Disney is constitutionally incapable of being. Disney has long been notorious for being very, very heavy on the control side of its IP. Buying something because of a fan community that you plan to essentially immediately squash is a rather silly acquisition. "Relatively permissive" here doesn't even have to mean IP abuse (which Disney certainly would squash), but even things like expressing unfiltered negative opinions. I just don't think Disney has the cultural DNA to deal with that in a way that even remotely resembles Twitter.
- knowtheory 10y agoWhat challenges does Twitter face that Disney doesn't already have to contend with via ownership of or stakes in ABC News, ESPN or Vice? Twitter doesn't host video of substantial duration or audio, and comment threads everywhere are already the same mess (just at a different scale w/r/t twitter).
- jerf 10y agoI don't think any of ABC News, ESPN, or Vice provide free forums for people to say whatever they want, do they? Twitter's more like blogspot or tumblr than a news comment site. Taking something like blogspot and turning into something highly regulated is a waste of everybody's time.
- coldcode 10y agoDisney cannot afford Twitter at current valuation. It makes no sense, they would more than double their LT debt, and it would provide no significant income. At 10% of its current market cap (around 2B) Twitter would be a fair deal. At the current value its a stupid purchase.
- bdavisx 10y agoIs Twitter a good place to work as an engineer? Does it have a great engineering culture? Does Disney? I'm just guessing here, but from the stories about how Disney did the whole import H1B people and have current employees train them before firing -- it doesn't sound like they (Disney) know how to treat software developers.
- gjolund 10y agoTwitter is desperate for anyone to take over their product and give them direction.