3 ms·
Except they're "disrupting" the taxi industry to get to that point. So they're destroying jobs and replacing them with less secure, less paid ones. (Wether or
by xg15 10y ago
Except they're "disrupting" the taxi industry to get to that point. So they're destroying jobs and replacing them with less secure, less paid ones.
(Wether or not that disruption has a positive effect for society in the big picture is another debate - but in terms of labor you can't ignore it)
- prostoalex 10y ago> replacing them with less secure, less paid ones My understanding is that people got in deep debt to the medallion owner, which they slowly repaid from taxi revenues. Are taxi jobs at the lowest rung that secure and well-paid?
- pdkl95 10y agoThe "medallion" system has its own problems, usually relating to monopoly power. The debt issue you mentioned is an example of that. However, Uber (and similar businesses like airbnb) are really little more than the exploitation of legal loopholes to bypass the usual costs of employment law and industry-specific regulations. Socializing expenses is always profitable, and its easy to beat existing players if you aren't paying the same expenses. Regarding job security, normal employees at least have a collection of legal protections that cover the employer-employee relationship. It's obviously not going to stop every type of abuse, but it's better than nothing. Some jurisdictions have started to catch up and force Uber et al to act properly, but as usual law is (very) slow to update.
- icebraining 10y agoTaxi drivers were already considered contractors. In fact, they are in a lawsuit against the taxi companies over that: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-03-26/news/chi-suit-taxi-drivers-should-be-considered-employees-20140326_1_taxi-drivers-yellow-cab-taxi-industry http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2014-03-26/news/chi-suit-... Which costs of employment that taxi companies paid is Uber bypassing? Please be specific instead of relying on rumor and propaganda.
- ezzaf 10y agoTaxi drivers are actually employees in some places? I had assumed most drivers were already under some non-employee structure in most jurisdictions pre-uber. That's certainly the case here in Australia where taxi drivers were making under minimum wage with working conditions that would not be allowed were they employees. It's hard to see Uber as any worse than what existed before.