3 ms·
#3, with HKPK and a transition period covered by CAs, is not entirely unreasonable and even offers some real advantages. The changeover doesn't need to take pla
by tedunangst 10y ago
#3, with HKPK and a transition period covered by CAs, is not entirely unreasonable and even offers some real advantages. The changeover doesn't need to take place at the stroke of midnight.
- geofft 10y agoYou could engineer #3 to work, but the big trouble is that occasionally someone will reinstall their web server from scratch (on purpose or as part of disaster recovery), lose the key, and expect not to lose their website permanently. I have yet to see any organization that deals usefully with changed SSH keys and communicates them properly instead of "oh yeah, we changed that, delete it from known_hosts and it'll be fine", and organizations that use SSH are more likely to know what they're doing than the average Internet site (in fact I count MIT's CS department as one of the guilty parties). An internet-wide equivalent of "yeah, just delete example.com from your known_hosts" is essentially an internet-wide announcement of "yeah, plz start MITMing example.com".