5 ms·
I'm an idiot here, so allow me this uninformed suggestion: Could the elephant's tusks be removed and replaced with false tusks? I'm assuming there would be som
by JKCalhoun 10y ago
I'm an idiot here, so allow me this uninformed suggestion:
Could the elephant's tusks be removed and replaced with false tusks? I'm assuming there would be some way to replace them the way an implant is used to replace a tooth in a human.
If the prosthetic tusk were obvious (a bright color for example) it would signal to the would-be poacher, "No ivory here."
The tusks removed would be destroyed.
- sliverstorm 10y agoAny scheme like this results in poachers killing the elephant so they don't wind up wasting time tracking it again later. I think this was discovered when they poisoned rhino horns (ground rhino horn is a traditional oral medicine) and marked them with bright color to identify them as poisoned. Poachers killed the marked rhinos and left the horns.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoThis suggests the obvious approach of poisoning the horn without dying it. Did anyone try that?
- csallen 10y agoThat's a very interesting ethical question. Maybe the better solution is to poison all the horns, but mark them as well.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoPoachers don't have to kill the animals just to save themselves time in the future. If you mark the horns, you leave yourself wide open to poachers killing the animals to get you to stop doing that.
- csallen 10y agoWell, considering the poachers' current strategy is already to kill as many animals as possible, I don't think that would be an effective move on their part. It's basically just the status quo, except now poachers are just wasting their time/ammo/money and not getting anything out of it.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoGood point.
- ericjang 10y agoAlong the subject of ethics... what about poisoning all the horns... but not marking them?
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoHow would that help? No one would know it was poisoned until the rhino was dead. The poachers wouldn't even find out until people stopped buying rhino horn because it was killing uneducated, superstitious people thousands of miles away - which is to say, far far too late. The loss of the rhino and the elephant would be tragic, but those people who consume it do not deserve to die - they don't understand what they're doing or what they're causing, and they are worth more than rhinos. Edit, since I can't respond to your comment: There is already an information battle to convince people that traffic in and using rhino horn is not possibly good for them. If they will not believe scientists telling them that, they won't believe it's poisoned. Nothing short of a mass market and culture shift is likely to change their beliefs. Telling them it's poisoned would certainly have too many misses and too little reach to be acceptable.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> How would that help? No one would know it was poisoned until the rhino was dead. The poachers wouldn't even find out until people stopped buying rhino horn because it was killing uneducated, superstitious people thousands of miles away. You would tell them. How do people currently know that rubbing alcohol has been poisoned? > Edit, since I can't respond to your comment: There is already an information battle to convince people that traffic in and using rhino horn is not possibly good for them. If they will not believe scientists telling them that, they won't believe it's poisoned. Nothing short of a mass market and culture shift is likely to change their beliefs. Telling them it's poisoned would certainly have too many misses and too little reach to be acceptable. 1. Yes, you can respond to any comment on its own page. 2. Yes, if the horns are actually poisoned, people will learn that they're poisoned. The feedback loop here is quite short: you announce that you've poisoned the rhino horns, people scoff, say "they'd never have the guts", and eat the horns, and then a lot of those people die. Word will get around. If they're not poisoned, then of course people won't believe that, but it's hard to blame them for accurately not believing your self-serving lies.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- gozur88 10y agoIf all the horns were taken there would be no point in killing elephants (or rhinos) to avoid tracking problems.
- Spare_account 10y agoRemoval sounds a little invasive but various schemes for sabotaging elephant tusk and rhino born have been proposed over the years. https://www.savetherhino.org/rhino_info/thorny_issues/dyeing_rhino_horn_and_elephant_ivory https://www.savetherhino.org/rhino_info/thorny_issues/dyeing...
- wehadfun 10y agoVariations of this come up all the time. Last reply I heard to this came down to. The difficulty of actually sedating the elephant. The danger of the elephants waking up during tusks removal and hurting them self or the remover. Poachers would still kill the elephant to avoid needlessly tracking it