5 ms·
I think that big people are discriminated against. I've experienced this in the workplace firsthand, where people were not hired for positions where their weigh
by imagist 10y ago
I think that big people are discriminated against. I've experienced this in the workplace firsthand, where people were not hired for positions where their weight had no bearing on their ability to perform the job.
However, obesity does have real health implications, and as such, weight loss is an effective treatment for obese people presenting with a wide variety of health problems. Recommending weight loss when weight loss is a low-risk, effective way to treat the patient's condition isn't discrimination, it's just proper medical practice.
The actual study cited in the article which is being cited as showing systemic discrimination: "The group concluded that heavy patients should first be counseled to lose weight because a lower weight reduces stress on the joints and can alleviate pain without surgery." There were, of course, exceptions to the rule mentioned.
So yes, I do think that fat people are discriminated against, but I do not think that recommending weight loss as treatment to obese patients is an example of discrimination.
- jakebasile 10y agoI agree that recommending weight loss is not discrimination in and of itself. I think that refusing to explore other treatment options in tandem is wrong, and I think that the comments in here blaming big people for being big as if it's a moral failing are discriminatory and ignorant.
- imagist 10y ago> I think that refusing to explore other treatment options in tandem is wrong, "Exploring other treatment options in tandem" in this case means cutting someone open and possibly killing them, in tandem with helping them lose weight, which would likely solve the problem by itself.