3 ms·
Somewhat off-topic, this article mentions a property of samples that has puzzled me for a long time. Maybe someone can shed light on that? [...] Field A would
by xg15 10y ago
Somewhat off-topic, this article mentions a property of samples that has puzzled me for a long time. Maybe someone can shed light on that?
[...] Field A would receive Fertilizer 1, Field B would receive Fertilizer 2, and so on.
But as Fisher pointed out, this type of experimentation was doomed to produce meaningless results. If the crops in Field A grew better than those in Field B, was that because Fertilizer 1 was better than Fertilizer 2? Or did Field A just happen to have richer soil?
[...] The way around the problem, Fisher concluded, was to apply different fertilizers to different small plots >at random<. [...] On average, the soil under Fertilizer 1 ought to look exactly like the soil under Fertilizer 2.
The article talks at length about how randomisation was the revolutionary new thing that Fisher introduced. Yet, in the given expample, it's the repetition of the experiment with different combinations of fields and fertilizers that does the trick, isn't it? It seems to me I should get the same results if I repeated the trial 50 times with Fertilizer 1 on field A and 50 times with 1 on field B.
So why is adding unpredictability (randomness) so important?
- xg15 10y ago... I didn't mean it to be that off topic. This got posted on the wrong thread, I'm sorry. If any mod could remove this, I'd be grateful.