4 ms·
The problem with an over-simplification, especially one that leads to a false equivalence (in this case calories != calories because it's an indirect measuremen
by WorldMaker 10y ago
The problem with an over-simplification, especially one that leads to a false equivalence (in this case calories != calories because it's an indirect measurement of energy by way of an energy by-product heat), is that it leads to drawing the wrong conclusions. Using CICO as a starting point in a diet is, best case, mostly harmless. On the other hand, it has been shown to be actually harmful to people's self-esteems and generally leads exactly to where we are with a steady stream of CICO "fad of the month diets" that don't produce general, reproducible results and can easily victim blame because "they weren't counting right".
Great, CICO might be a useful superstition for you. I'm not going to stop you from using it just as I'm not going to stop people from consulting their astrology charts. I do take umbrage at anyone that thinks CICO is good science; it really is about as much science as astrology.
- jtuente 10y ago> harmful to people's self-esteems Hoo boy, that's what we need, more people with self-inflated self-esteem issues. I think what you mean is that it's harmful to their immediate gratification response. > CICO "fad of the month diets" Could you point one of those out to me, because the only CICO diets I'm aware of are things like Jenny Craig and Weight Watchers (oh and maybe Nutrisystem). Shit like South Beach, Atkins, Low-GI, Keto aren't focused on CICO, but on some other aspect of nutritional content.
- WorldMaker 10y agoFrom what I've read, and I know I'm veering towards stuff I don't have the place to discuss, both Jenny Craig and Weight Watchers seem to go through fad periods themselves, measurement revamps, have different scoring systems between each other, etc. There are blogs and tumblrs devoted to the cycles that Jenny Craig and Weight Watchers tend to go through and the abusive victim blaming to people that occurs within their programs, especially to "repeat customers". You might not care anything about that sort of abuse (and in fact from many of your responses seem more than happy to fat shame), but it is a real problem that is hurting real people, compassion would go a long way...
- jtuente 10y agoFor as long as those two have been around, I would expect that they have had to adjust their system based on the changes in nutritional science and to better balance their scoring systems (much like video games often do). Abusive victim blaming? Really? You mean people don't like being told they're fat. That the only reason they aren't losing weight is because they aren't staying true to their diet. Don't get me wrong, some people are downright abusive, but that falls on the individual not the diet system. On the other hand if you're a repeat customer to something like this, it really shows you aren't learning how to control your diet on your own (which should be the ultimate goal of these programs, I don't know). I don't put any stock in blogs that dedicate themselves to finding these stories to share (I consider them something akin to conspiracy websites, very different from, say, Yelp). A program so focused on customer abuse should have closed up shop long ago from a lack of customers.
- WorldMaker 10y agoFor as long as those two have been around I'd expect they'd have solved weight loss entirely if it was truly as simple as CICO. I'd assume they would have worked themselves out of a business model. They are both for-profit companies and their revenues rely as much on that fact that they don't actually solve the problem as they do on revamping the system every few years to score new customers or returning old customers.
- jazzyk 10y agoSuperstition? Astrology? I think you never took a physics class? Please check the law of conservation of energy[1]. A human being is an isolated system, to lose body mass, you need Energy Used > Energy ingested. We may not measure caloric values of food properly, and depending on our genetics and age our caloric expenditures/activity will vary. However imprecise, comparing caloric values of chips (150kcal/oz) and leeks (16 kcals/oz) should still tell you something. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conservation_of_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conservation_of_energy
- WorldMaker 10y agoFirst of all, a human body is not an isolated system from a law of conservation of energy standpoint. A human body is a complex ecology of micro-organisms and chemical processes with different energy needs, storage solutions, masses. A human body is continually interacting with its environments including factors that we are just now starting to truly analyze such as the microbiome, which is the crux of the article referenced here. But that is beside the point, calories != energy (which is properly Joules now in SI system) on either side of the CICO scale, especially the "energy used" side. It's not just a matter of precision, calories are an approximation to energy at best. But if you want to argue that calories on the input side are still useful, I get that calories can sometimes be a useful first pass approximation, especially to numbers-minded software folks that like easy metrics, and there are plenty of examples where comparing two calorie numbers gives you a reasonable approximation of the comparative "weight" of foods. But there are also plenty of counter-examples: most Diet Sodas have less calories than their "non-diet" counterparts but the science doesn't seem to bear out that they are "healthier"; olestra chips had lower calories than other chips but were determined to be rather unhealthy to the digestive system and people gained weight eating them... Calories don't tell you anything about what is in the food or how the body will react to it. I get that as software-minded people we like nice easy metrics, but calories are not a good metric.
- jtuente 10y agoNow that was entirely pedantry. The microbiome isn't excluded from the law of conservation of energy either. Different microbiomes may process food differently, but it cannot extract more energy than is available. A calorie is a unit of measure of energy, specifically the energy required to increase the temperature of 1g of water 1C. The fact that it is inconsistent based on temperature and pressure doesn't invalidate its definition. It is approximately 4.184J. Your example of diet soda is completely off the point as well. A lot of poisons have 0 calories, that doesn't make them good diet food. Olestra is another bad example, because the rats in the experiment didn't gain weight from the olestra but from a feedback effect that resulted in further overeating. But you're right in that calories don't tell you whether something you eat is poisonous. Calories are a good enough metric, but they require regular reevaluation in order to make decisions.