3 ms·
Except medicine works on different principles than Ockham razor. Such as the Hippocrates oath some doctors selectively forget. (2nd and 4th verse of modern vers
by AstralStorm 10y ago
Except medicine works on different principles than Ockham razor. Such as the Hippocrates oath some doctors selectively forget. (2nd and 4th verse of modern version)
A doctor is not supposed to stop or not attempt treatment because a person is fat... which is a kind of sickness, not really a choice. Not should they stop at the most obvious issue, especially when it takes years to fix.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoDiagnosis works on Occam's razor most of the time. Yes it could be a tumor or degenerative bone disease, but its probably just a sprain (because you twisted it hard while playing basketball). In fact Occam's razor describes medicine perfectly. As for the 2nd part - my back hurts and I'm fat - weight-related for 99% of the patients. Fixing weight fixes the back (and the feet and the knees and on and on). Any other treatment is palliative but doesn't address the fundamental cause. It would be irresponsible to keep giving obese patients 'crutches' (treating the complaint) when the cure is weight control.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThis applies only for movement disorders (e.g. joint damage) directly caused by obesity, maybe. Which the doctor gets to prove by excluding other reasonable causes existing in non-obese people. No shortcuts.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoAnd blood pressure? Circulation issues? Cholesterol? Diabetes? Arthritis? Sleep apnea? Depression? All of those cluster around obesity. The simplest, most direct and most effective cure is controlling weight.