3 ms·
The point of bringing up calories in, calories out is not to argue that everyone has the same metabolism, it's to point out that weight changes must be related
by maxerickson 10y ago
The point of bringing up calories in, calories out is not to argue that everyone has the same metabolism, it's to point out that weight changes must be related to the difference between calories in and calories out. People may argue it dogmatically, but I think most people saying it will concede that it is strongest when it is in terms of actual calories absorbed vs actual calories burned (Rather than estimates).
Sure, someone that absorbs more calories will have to adjust their consumed calories down more than someone who is less efficient, but if they adjust their calories in to be less than their calories out, they will indeed lose weight over time.
It might seem absurd that people actually say "physics still applies", but they are usually saying it in response to arguments that are physically impossible, not in response to nuanced arguments about weight loss being more difficult in some cases.