3 ms·
You have completely missed the point. Contrasting economic systems is completely irrelevant. The choice here is not between different economic systems, but bet
by barrkel 17y ago
You have completely missed the point. Contrasting economic systems is completely irrelevant.
The choice here is not between different economic systems, but between different moral systems.
You cannot make a free market your moral system because markets are amoral. That is, it is not that they are not immoral and so should be replaced with something else; rather, they have no moral content - morality comes from somewhere else.
You can pay someone to punch a third party in the nose. You get the value of knowing that someone is going to get hurt. The other guy gets your money. The transaction, in the free market, by itself has no moral content, though. A free market just means exchanging value for mutual gain. It doesn't say that those values have positive or negative moral worth.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tkahn6 17y agoDo not confuse capitalism with anarchism. Capitalism believes in a government which protects private property and human life with physical force. You can pay someone to punch someone else, but that's inconsistent with capitalistic philosophy.
- barrkel 17y agoWhy would a government protect human life with physical force? Remember, the justification must be from a free market, not with reference to some other moral system. What, in a free market moral system, prevents slavery? The justification must come from the free market, if free market is to be the moral system.
- tkahn6 17y agoThe justification must come from the free market, if free market is to be the moral system. How can there exist a free market without the guarantee of the protection of private property? Without that you have anarchy (whoever is physically strongest wins). I've never heard of someone invoking the idea of a "free market" without implying that the agents of the market are protected from physical harm. This is by no means 'official' but from the first sentence of the article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market: "A free market is a market without economic intervention and regulation by government except to outlaw and prosecute force or fraud." When people say "free market" this is what they imply. What, in a free market moral system, prevents slavery? The government.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoHow can there exist a free market without the guarantee of the protection of private property? Without that you have anarchy See "anarcho-capitalism": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho-capitalism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho-capitalism In an anarcho-capitalist society, law enforcement, courts, and all other security services would be provided by voluntarily-funded competitors such as private defense agencies rather than through taxation, and money would be privately and competitively provided in an open market. You continue... > > What, in a free market moral system, prevents slavery? > The government. No. Slavery is prevented because the income generated by those would-be slaves is less than the income generated when those people fill the role of "consumer". Also, if there are non-consensual exchanges, then by definition it is not a free market, but that simply avoids the question...
- Psyonic 17y agoHow do you figure that prevents slavery? It doesn't prevent slavery right now... buying a russian sex slave and making her work 12 hour days in a club seems to generate a lot more income than she would as a "consumer".
- CWuestefeld 17y agoI could turn the question around and ask you how the government prevents this, as the foundation of your question assumes that it's not doing so.
- oconnore 17y agoYour use of "moral content" is entirely ambiguous, because that content will vary depending on which moral system you refer. And since a market is essentially an amalgamation of individuals (whom likely have or are capable of inducing moral content through their actions and desires), it is likely that a market has a great deal of moral content regardless of which system you pick.
- barrkel 17y agoThe moral system I'm referring to is the moral system called "free market" - which is what the article actually says.
- cynicalkane 17y agoFalse distinction. The GP is saying that economic systems are moral systems. He even says why, and cites examples. He didn't miss your point. He saw your point, and thinks it's wrong.