6 ms·
I was wondering how airlines were going to cut emissions. Turns out they're not. To be clear, the 15-year agreement would not force airlines to cut their pollu
by sp332 10y ago
I was wondering how airlines were going to cut emissions. Turns out they're not.
To be clear, the 15-year agreement would not force airlines to cut their pollution. Instead, companies would compensate for any emissions growth after the accord begins in 2020 by buying credits that back renewable energy development, forest preservation or other environmental endeavors.
- surfmike 10y agoSince emissions will cost more, they'll have more incentive to upgrade their fleets to more efficient planes.
- sp332 10y agoSure, but the incentives are mostly already there. And they're not buying the new super-efficient large jets because they have a hard time selling enough tickets to fill them. So I don't think they're going to be physically able to reduce emissions too much further, certainly not enough to hold overall emissions steady as flights rack up 3x as many miles over the next few decades. To put it a different way, most of the advances here will not be in more efficient ways to fly, but in more effective ways to sell carbon credits to the airlines.
- cossatot 10y agoOffsets/credits are a fine idea, assuming they work. And forest preservation by Brazil would hopefully be domestic, and not chopping down the Amazon has additional non-carbon environmental bonuses.
- phkahler 10y agoWhat a great barrier to competition. If a smaller airline grows, they'll have to buy "credits". Cap and Trade is political bullshit. If you want to tax carbon emissions, tax the fuel coming out of the ground and let the drillers and diggers pass that on to whomever uses the fuel. It's the only way to be fair about it. Otherwise just accept that this is nothing more than a political game.
- lmm 10y ago> If you want to tax carbon emissions, tax the fuel coming out of the ground and let the drillers and diggers pass that on to whomever uses the fuel. Isn't that what cap and trade is? What's the distinction here?
- wyager 10y agoAirlines are paying for any additional growth after 2020, not for current pollution.
- stinkytaco 10y agoCap and trade limits emissions, but then allows you to buy off that limit by paying what amounts to a fine, but a fine that is directed at certain uses (sustainable energy, etc.). One could argue it's not really a market based solution to the problem, since unless the "trade" is high enough, there's no real reason to address the actual problem -- emissions. Making fuel more expensive would force companies to adjust to an immediate operating cost, rather than being able to lobby for higher "caps" or lower "trades". You are essentially creating a new market (with its own rules and inefficiencies), instead of trying to manage an existing one. The problem with taxing the oil coming out of the ground is the incredibly complex nature of an unstable global market that is managed largely by a small number of players artificially controlling the price and a whole futures market trying to hedge against that roller coaster. It's also a market that wars are literally fought over. Finally, it's political suicide since it will impact consumers directly in the amount it costs them to fill their cars instead of indirectly, which they are less likely to blame on oil taxes.
- phkahler 10y ago>> The problem with taxing the oil coming out of the ground is the incredibly complex nature of an unstable global market... Just put a fixed tax per barrel, or per carbon atom, or whatever. The tax shouldn't depend on the price paid for the oil. Just put $1 for every barrel pumped in the US, and every barrel imported and presto - $19M per day of tax revenue ($7B per year) without a major impact to the consumer, and without creating that new market for credits and the associated politics. Do the equivalent for coal and gas too - you know all the carbon sources. People act like passing on a price increase is going to hurt their business, but when everyone has to do it that's not true.