7 ms·
Animals used for meat production are bred for their feed conversion ratio [1] i.e. how much body mass can they produce for a given amount of food. If this can v
by gadders 10y ago
Animals used for meat production are bred for their feed conversion ratio [1] i.e. how much body mass can they produce for a given amount of food. If this can vary within other mammals, I don't see a reason why it couldn't happen in humans. I'm not sure if it would necessarily be microbiome related.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_conversion_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_conversion_ratio
- hammock 10y agoSurprised this isn't referenced more when people bring up "calories in, calories out" edit: see my child comment if you somehow think I am arguing against the concept
- jtuente 10y agoProbably because it's still irrelevant to CICO. CICO doesn't tell you how much calories go in or out, rather it tells you to measure them wherever possible and make adjustments based on your weight changes.
- hammock 10y agoIt is relevant. You might have thought I meant it debunks it (or supports it), what I meant was it adds color to it. Conversion ratio allows you to quantify the difference from one person to another (the "adjustments based on weight change" you refer to)
- WorldMaker 10y agoI still think calories in health science are the last bastion of phlogiston in any of the sciences. It's a deeply over-simplifying metric that implies a false equivalency. We estimate the calories in food by the amount of heat equivalent they create when burnt. We estimate the calorie usage of a human body by the heat it produces during the effort. None of those estimates do justice to the complex biology and chemistry processes at work: not all calories are equal, they never have been, they never will be. (Humans aren't just heat-producing machines. Digestion is nothing at all like producing raw heat from food.) ETA: It's the health science equivalent of the physics spherical cow fallacy writ large and taken dogmatically.
- DougWebb 10y agoIt's kind of like measuring the performance of vehicles by looking only at the chemical energy of the fuel they use and how far they go on a given amount of fuel. Those seem like reasonable measurements, until you try to put jet fuel in a motorcycle or bunker oil in your car. The design, efficiency, and maintenance status of the engine matters a lot.
- jtuente 10y agoWell of course CICO is an oversimplification, it's supposed to be. It's meant to be the basis of the diet. Your analogy is about as useful as saying 2-dimensional kinematics doesn't translate to 3-dimensional kinematics because it doesn't have a component for handling the third dimension.
- DougWebb 10y agoExcept it doesn't translate, when you're trying to handle the third dimension. And CICO isn't an effective basis for your diet when there are biological factors with large impacts that CICO simply doesn't address.
- jtuente 10y agoWhat large factors outweigh calorie content? There are plenty of dietary restrictions for things like Crohn's and diabetes, but they're easily worked around without changing overall calorie consumption. Hypothyroidism and other metabolic diseases can't cause weight gain without an overabundance of calories consumed. The fact that someone's BMR lowers because of them is not a bigger factor than how much calories a person consumes.
- jtuente 10y agoGood job, you've expounded on the obvious short-coming of "simplification". Most people have a hard enough time with algebra, how do you expect them to handle the many complexities of human biology and the digestive process. CICO is meant as a starting point in a diet, not a be-all, end-all encompassing idea. The spherical cow exists to simplify ideas so they can be more easily grasped and learned.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe point of bringing up calories in, calories out is not to argue that everyone has the same metabolism, it's to point out that weight changes must be related to the difference between calories in and calories out. People may argue it dogmatically, but I think most people saying it will concede that it is strongest when it is in terms of actual calories absorbed vs actual calories burned (Rather than estimates). Sure, someone that absorbs more calories will have to adjust their consumed calories down more than someone who is less efficient, but if they adjust their calories in to be less than their calories out, they will indeed lose weight over time. It might seem absurd that people actually say "physics still applies", but they are usually saying it in response to arguments that are physically impossible, not in response to nuanced arguments about weight loss being more difficult in some cases.
- elsherbini 10y agoIn fact, many livestock are given subtheraputic antibiotic doses[0] to increase their weight gain, but the mechanism isn't known for why it works. In that case it feels like it almost has to be a shift of the bacterial community that causes it. [0] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2015&q=subtherapeutic+antibiotic+use+in+livestock&hl=en&as_sdt=0,22&as_vis=1 https://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2015&q=subtherapeu...
- chriskanan 10y agoWhile that's true, the hypothesis in the paper is consistent with feeding antibiotics to livestock to improve their feed conversion ratio by decreasing the diversity of bacteria in their microbiomes [0, 1]. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1804117/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1804117/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibiotic_use_in_livestock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibiotic_use_in_livestock