9 ms·
Stackoverflow works great for me, and I don't know why more people don't appear to use it like I do. 1) When you've got a problem, Google it. 98% of the time
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
Stackoverflow works great for me, and I don't know why more people don't appear to use it like I do.
1) When you've got a problem, Google it. 98% of the time the answer will be in top 5 links to stackoverflow or documentation. You upvote the answer and question.
2) 1.5% of the time, stackoverflow will have a related question, but either it doesn't have an answer, or the answer has issues.
You figure it out yourself, so you post a comment or answer or just the crappy workaround you used because you ran out of time to figure it out completely.
3) The remaining 0.5% of the time, you get nothing. You post a question, but of course nobody answers because it's an esoteric, hard question. 24 hours later you post an answer to your own question, or more likely a crappy workaround.
And eventually somebody posts a great answer to your question. (Once this happened to me >3 years after I posted it!) It's way too late for you, but it will help the next person with the same problem.
You don't get a lot of karma quickly this way since you're posting esoteric stuff, but you do tend to pick up some badges that are designed to reward this sort of behaviour, like "Populist" and "Necromancer". You do pick up karma slowly and steadily, though. What's satisfying is seeing an answer tick over from zero to one ~12 months after you posted it, realising that you saved somebody hours of frustration.
If you answer an easy question, you've saved somebody a few minutes. When you answer a hard one, you've saved hours or days.
- fixermark 10y agoConcur. I remember the days prior to Stackoverflow (where the average search for a programming question landed me on expertsexchange). They were not good days.
- epaga 10y agoTop 2% here - I have used Stackoverflow this way for years. It has saved me hundreds of hours of searching over the years and still does. One thing I'd add is I try to leave a thank you comment in addition to an upvote when I find an answer to a hard question. Getting comments years later thanking you for a quick answer you jotted down at some point is so satisfying.
- alexc05 10y agoI have a question about nodejs from 2011 that still gets comments and upvotes regularly. One of my favorite parts I think is the fact that the correct answer changed over time, so I continued to update the question. At first the answer to "how to read a file one line at a time" was to use a module, later, a better module came along, eventually nodejs finally added native support for file reading. I had an "annual update" going for a while since the correct answer changed to often. Eventually someone came along and completely rewrote my question. Wiped all the history, evolution, etc... And boiled it down to "use native" I was saddened a little, but understood. I find a number of stack overflow rules/guidelines to be odd. For example: 'do not say "thanks" or "hello" people reading your question do not have time for that's [sic] It's definitely a community which has been usurped by the aspie side of programming That said, I still get thanks on it and it makes me smile when I do
- crispyambulance 10y agoIronically, leaving a "thank you" will typically get deletions/nags from the self-appointed comment police. As much as I like (and heavily use) SO, it has a real problem with making people feel like shit when asking, answering and commenting. There are people who are exemplary in their politeness and helpfulness like the top-contributor, John Skeet. There are also quite "mean" people like Hans Passant (also super-high score). I wish more people would use the really fantastic users like Skeet as an example of how to behave. "Game-ification" strategies in social networks like SO tends to attract uncharitable, persnickety rule-zealots and this seems to have been re-enforced over the years.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThe "comment police" bit is an interesting observation - much of the really petty hostility seems to come from mid-tier power users instead of mods and high-level contributors. I think the article here undervalues how unpleasant it is for a new programmer to get even a single response of "Seriously? Marking for deletion." Those comments might get removed later, but saying "trolls are everywhere" is too pat when the people abusing new users are very visibly established, popular members of the community. Getting attacked by a random throwaway account is a very different feeling than getting attacked by someone up near the top of the totem pole.
- lmg643 10y agoI taught myself to code using SO in just the last two years. I reference it almost daily. I've shipped production software in this time span using the information. I can't believe such a high quality source of information exists on the internet, it is a phenomenal public resource. Difficult to contribute to? Sure. Prickly moderators, who close questions I've found very useful? Definitely. Is it dying? I have no idea, I hope not. The creators of the site deserve some kind of medal, in addition to whatever valuation the company has. Really an incredible resource.
- Bartweiss 10y agoI wonder if these days SO could move to a revenue model of just asking software companies for money. The entire community certainly owes them a debt for how much they've streamlined working with unfamiliar tools. "We make all of your programmers 50% more efficient, kick us a little cash to keep us running smoothly."
- bozho 10y agoExactly. And that's good enough. The question whether contributors "are welcome" is less relevant now than it was 5 years ago. But I think they still are.
- pinouchon 10y agoStackoverflow can be thought of a big cache for programming problems. A hit is a +1 on question/answer and walk away with the answer. A miss is when you have to find the answer someplace else (or figure it out yourself), then you make the cache bigger.
- asimuvPR 10y agoIt beats having to use the man pages 100% of the time, which is how I had to do it before the web had accessible technical content.
- Chathamization 10y agoOne issue I run into is finding a Stack Overflow question that exactly matches the issue I've run into, find that it's been closed for being a duplicate, click the link to the question it's supposed to be a duplicate of, and find that the other question is completely unrelated. Not only can I not find the answer from SO at this point, but if I find the answer on my own I can't even help others. Another issue I've run into is the minimum numbers of characters needed to edit an answer. Once I found the answer that was chosen and upvoted had code that didn't make any sense. It was something like an instance of a point object "point1" and an instance "newpoint" and they wrote "point1 = newpoint;" but actually meant "point1 = new point();". When I realized the problem I tried to change it but wasn't able to because I wasn't changing the answer enough (I think there's a minimum 6 character limit). I didn't want to make random changes elsewhere just to make the minimum needed to fix it, so I let it be. I find Stack Overflow useful, but I don't try to participate in it anymore and don't stay signed in.
- corobo 10y agoThe ones that really get my gripe are the ones that are flagged for being off topic.. Off what topic? This is a place where technical questions are asked and answered and this is a technical question that needs answering - Why is it closed?
- dhimes 10y agoExactly. Double frustration if it was the first return from google.
- corobo 10y agoThat's the only way visit SO. It's double frustration all the time.
- wyldfire 10y agoI don't necessarily agree with the logic, but SO's "topic" is software development. Many questions that are technical but not regarding software are closed for being off topic. Some/many are migrated to sibling stackexchange sites. Some questions are closed because they require opinion-based answers ("What's the best ...?", e.g.).
- zamalek 10y agoAgreed. This related to the misconception that "little or no activity on an open source project means that it's dead." That statement is frequently true, but not always. If most of the common questions have been answered, then there will obviously be a correlated decline in the number of questions posted and subsequently answers posted. Esoteric questions aren't abundant, especially over a constant time frame. Declining question/answer activity shows that the website is healthy. I've opened S/O a few times over the past year with the intention to answer questions, only to find duplicate/off-topic/low-effort/etc. questions.
- sporkenfang 10y agoStackoverflow is a good language resource for me -- if I don't know the language I'm working in as well yet, it's invaluable. For non-beginner questions I don't find your percentages to be accurate, apologies. In the latter case SO (and hell sometimes even googling the problem) are unhelpful, and whatever is on SO that is related isn't applicable enough to be helpful. In these cases sometimes I find myself asking SO questions, but more often than not after about ten minutes of searching I go offline in my quest and find a senior+ engineer who has a free moment to ask.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoP.S. for SO devs, how about an "Advanced Necromancer" gold badge? 1 year and 10 points rather than 60 days and 5 points for the current silver?
- Shog9 10y agoCould we get away with calling it "Lich King", ya think?
- Mithaldu 10y agoAll the "works for me" answers like yours and the articles are just another example of what's wrong with SO. I was tempted to qualify this more, but honestly, if you can't see why "works for me" is one of the worst kinds of answers you can give in tech, then i doubt i can convince you.
- bendbro 10y agoSorry, I fail to see that. Works for me works great for me ninety percent of the time.
- wpietri 10y agoWhen a person says, "I'm having a problem" and the response is, "Well I'm not having any problem, buh-bye!" it in effect says "I don't care that you have a problem." Often the real problem for novices is that they don't know enough to ask the right question; good questions require that you already be pretty close to the answer. So the real process of helping somebody with technology often begins by turning a bad question into a good question. So basically, I think "works for me" is disrespectful. Mostly I see it used defensively; the goal is to make the querent go away again. If somebody doesn't want to help, fine, I respect that. But in that case, they should not put themselves into a position where they are answering questions from novices.
- initram 10y ago>When a person says, "I'm having a problem" and the response is, "Well I'm not having any problem, buh-bye!" it in effect says "I don't care that you have a problem." What a bizarre interpretation. When someone says, "It works for me," they're saying "I tried your example because I want to help, but was unable to reproduce your problem. Maybe there's some information you didn't provide that can explain the difference between what I'm seeing and what you're seeing? Please add more information so I can understand what's different and help you."
- wpietri 10y ago
- pjc50 10y agoAs others have said, the first objective of stackoverflow was to destroy expertexchange, which it has succeeded admirably at. Finding answers through search engines is now far easier. I've posted very rarely on the software stackexchange, but I've been very active on the electronics stackexchange to the extent that I'm in the top 2% and rank #28. It has very aggressive moderation of 'bad' questions, and I sometimes wish there was somewhere chattier and less fussy we could gently steer the less well formed questions to. It does feel bad when someone asks a question and gets the door slammed in their face. But on the other hand there are a lot of repetitive 'bad' questions from people who've not yet understood what a resistor is. Remember it's been gamified, so we might as well treat it as a game. Consider the motivation of the question-answerers. (I also opportunistically karma-snipe the "hot network questions", so I have 1.4k rep on math.stackexchange from only two answers)
- dionidium 10y agoI've earned "Necromancer" about a dozen times and I don't think it's a coincidence that they're some of the answers I'm most pleased with. I don't even bother answering old questions unless I think there's a clear gap in the existing answers that I can help fill.
- kzisme 10y agoDo you normally answer older questions that have already been answered, or newer questions with a few sub-optimal answers? I find that most older questions have pretty useful answers so I can't really improve upon them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fiatjaf 10y agoExactly what I do. Exactly what happens to me. I am a serious Necromancer.