4 ms·
The only problem with repairing devices is labour cost, nothing else. I've had a broken subwoofer that I took to a small electronics shop(in UK), and was quote
by gambiting 10y ago
The only problem with repairing devices is labour cost, nothing else.
I've had a broken subwoofer that I took to a small electronics shop(in UK), and was quoted 60 pounds to even have it looked at. Not repaired - looked at. The subwoofer cost me 80 pounds on ebay. So predictably, it went straight to the bin.
Same with washing machines, dryers, etc - I bought a Hotpoint washing machine for 220 pounds, but a standard call out charge for an engineer to come and have a look is at least 100 pounds. Plus any parts + cost of labour billed per hour = it's cheaper to just buy a new washing machine and at least have a warranty on it.
Now, I feel like this is exclusive to western countries, because people value their time a lot(as they should!) - but where I'm from(Poland) it would be stupidly cheap to get anything repaired. I had an old LCD TV repaired locally, the guy spent half a day fixing it, and only charged 100 zlotys(20 pounds/30 USD) - that included parts.
Not sure how we can change that, unless we get the labour cost down.
- gmac 10y agoOn your subwoofer, you can try listing that kind of thing on Freecycle/Freegle. Commonly someone technically competetent will pick it up to see if they can fix it.
- kaybe 10y agoSome cities also have repair cafes, where skilled idealistic people hang out with tools and help you try to fix it yourself.
- aembleton 10y agoWe could start sending items to Poland for repair.
- dTal 10y agoPart of the problem is globalisation. Things are made in places with cheap labour, and sold in places with expensive labour. But it seems to me like the problem is equally that new goods are too cheap, rendering labour unable to compete. There are many externalised costs to a new product not reflected in the price (or we wouldn't even be having this discussion) - the environmental cost of manufacture, the environmental cost of disposing of the thing it replaced, the raw materials we unsustainably mined. Fixing this directly is politically untenable because we'd have to drastically raise the price of everything. This Swedish tax break scheme is actually sort of an underhanded way of doing just that - to compensate for the lost revenue other taxes will go up (or the currency will inflate - either way everything costs more).
- kalleboo 10y ago> Not sure how we can change that, unless we get the labour cost down. If my living was covered by basic income, playing electronics detective and fixing broken stuff sounds like a somewhat fun and fulfilling job (even though 90% of my day may be spent replacing caps). Or I may have just been watching too many electronics YouTube videos lately...
- hx87 10y agoIf cheap labor is the problem then it is also the solution. Ship the subwoofer to the country that produced it for cheap, and have the cheap labor there repair it.
- sliverstorm 10y agoInterestingly, I wonder if labor (a major factor in repair as you say) is essentially irrelevant to the climate, and thus make spending copious labor, in stiu of more shipping & manufacture, the best thing environmentally. Shipping things around burns petroleum, but human labor costs mostly time (no climate impact) and calories, which are largely being burned anyway simply by existing. (Though this changes a little if we're talking hard manual labor instead of delicate work with the hands)