9 ms·
Mervyn King, formerly of the Bank of England, in "The End of Alchemy" has a great parable of an island populated by fishermen. It starts with a pretty basic nee
by prostoalex 10y ago
Mervyn King, formerly of the Bank of England, in "The End of Alchemy" has a great parable of an island populated by fishermen. It starts with a pretty basic need of financing the nets and boats to do the fishing, where the lender then gets slowly repaid with the fish caught.
At some point a finance person steps in and introduces a credit lending facility, which overall is a good thing for the health of the economy. Then, in decision to not take on too much risk, the said finance person offloads the loans in a securitized fashion to other wealthy islanders who then benefit from fishing booms and receive below average returns in years that are dry.
Then another finance person figures out the futures contracts, which act as insurance to fishermen and guarantee a reasonable price even at times of market over-supply.
At some point trading the loan securities and fishing future contracts starts paying more than humble fishing, which means that the best and brightest switch into finance, creating a stigma for fishing as less desirable occupation for under-achievers. Majority of island's GDP is now comprised of fishing-related loans and futures, with fishing itself occupying a relatively small niche.
This, of course, collapses at some point, but the problem is that it's hard to point out that one step that's completely irrational and bonkers - everything created by finance industry has found some demand among fishermen and simplified their lives.
- mjevans 10y agoI'd speculate that it's the point at which the insurance and futures markets allow for buyers that are unprepared or unable to prepare for actually receiving a shipment. This leads to a market in which speculation is allowed, instead of biding on the actual outcome of supply/demand interacting.
- harryh 10y agoIt's interesting that you think speculation is bad and yet you're sitting there speculating. Kind of self refuting no?
- atroyn 10y agoThis isn't necessarily so clear cut. Some percentage of market activity due to speculation helps to smooth capital flows over time. In an industry like fishing, profitable speculation can keep the industry afloat in tough times (e.g buying up fishing debt in a slump for pennies on the dollar because you know the fish are still there and this was just a bad season) or damp down an overheated and unsustainable market (e.g. shorting fishing futures).
- dangerlibrary 10y agoMaybe I'm jaded or missing something obvious, but the point that seems bonkers to me is the part where the loan originator offloads 100% of the risk in the loans they originated. That seems like a very clear principle / agent problem where the originator no longer bears any risk for loan failure, only failure to sell the loan. That creates incentives for increasingly complicated/opaque packaging of loans that fail to sell - CDOs.
- Zigurd 10y agoExactly. If you don't believe finanicialization is a problem, you have a tendency to believe more financial instruments are a good solution in all cases. You have only a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
- prostoalex 10y agoHaving the pendulum swing to another opposite (requiring 100% of the loans to be kept on books) creates two problems I can see. Only wealthiest institutions can participate, so in good times rich get richer. It also creates a monopsony of loan buyers, likely increasing the costs of borrowing.
- atroyn 10y agoBoth good points. I'd also note that it would be very hard if not impossible to legislate for the 'right' kinds of risk arbitrage and against the 'wrong' ones.
- donw 10y agoI suspect that legislation will never be able to run ahead of the human capacity to rapidly and efficiently paint oneself into a corner. Rather than trying to prevent the resulting busts at all costs, it seems that it would be more effective to work towards building support systems that are antifragile in the face of economic downturns. Or have I totally missed the point here?
- ScottBurson 10y ago
- Waterluvian 10y agoTo me the bottom line is: people and companies who want to cut the pie to get crumbs. The more they cut, the more crumbs. But also the more likely it is that the pie crumbles.
- avip 10y agoSee also Schiff's How an Economy Grows and Why It Crashes
- nstj 10y ago> At some point trading the loan securities and fishing future contracts starts paying more than humble fishing This analogy relies on the financiers being either good speculators and arbitrageurs of risk, or charging high fees, ie: they need to get their high "fish salary" from somewhere. Point is that the two reasons the financiers are being well paid are either that they're good at their job (a good thing), or that they're bilking the fishermen out of their output (which relies on the fishermen being conned into paying for overpriced financial services).
- icefox 10y agoIf each fisherman is willing to pay some trivial amount say $3 each year for some service that they find significant value out of than they are happy. Finance seems to often behave like programming where they do it at scale. When there are 12.3 million fisherman you could argue that the fisherman are indeed being conned into paying for overpriced financial services. But then you get into a question of value. Perhaps it is actually worth $300/year to each fisherman for this service and that is where it started and was only driven down to $3 by competition (and yet still very profitable as it only actually costs say 30cents on average)
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> It starts with a pretty basic need of financing the nets and boats to do the fishing, where the lender then gets slowly repaid with the fish caught. > At some point a finance person steps in and introduces a credit lending facility It sounds like there was already a credit lending facility? As far as I can tell, "credit lending" just means giving someone a loan now in exchange for being paid back (more, usually) later. > At some point trading the loan securities and fishing future contracts starts paying more than humble fishing Historically, the point at which this occurs is the introduction of loans and futures. There's no transition point. Assuming an economy consisting solely of fishers and financiers, compensation for financiers is limited by the amount of fish produced, but it's quite possible even then that one financier produces more fish than one fisherman does. And your example presumes other classes of workers when fishing requires nets and boats as capital goods. > This, of course, collapses at some point, but the problem is that it's hard to point out that one step that's completely irrational and bonkers You say that like a collapse demonstrates that a mistake occurred at some point. Everything collapses some of the time.
- Nursie 10y agoPretty much by definition, the financier is not producing any fish. Their utility is in providing finance for the industry. While this does seem to have utility, in and of itself it doesn't produce anything. It is a role that exists to manipulate and imaginary construct (money).
- thaumasiotes 10y agoIf removing the financier causes fish production to drop, the financier was producing fish.
- Nursie 10y agoThey mat, through directing caputal flows, have enabled more fish production. They certainly did not produce a single anchovy. More likely, they inserted themselves into the production cycle somewhere they weren't needed, and started creaming off a proportion of the fisb trade, while actually adding nothing of value to the process.
- wallace_f 10y agoThis is a great comment. I hope it reaches many people. In the spirit of this comment, and I can't find the particular article I'm looking for right now, but Paul Krugman many years back was writing about how financial services should move more towards a public utility model. The argument is, we would all be better off if we separate off all the risk-taking in finance to for-profit companies that can fail without posing greater risk to the economy. The more mundane, more-necessary, day-to-day financing that we all need (home loans, etc.), according to Krugman, should move to the public utility model. It's not complicated and if the companies that do these jobs fail they pose enormous risk to the entire economy. This is the analogy I can think of: If our water company became bigger, more risk-friendly, and more profit-oriented, people would obviously know that is ridiculous. Basic financial services is not any more complicated, to be honest. The welfare of humanity would benefit enormously from an even more robust version of Glass-Steagall, but the finance industry is so entrenched in US politics I don't see it happening.
- mtgx 10y agoWould that be the same Paul Krugman who only a few months ago said the big banks are not a systemic threat anymore, in an effort to undermine Bernie Sanders' anti-big bank message? http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/elizabeth-warren-big-banks_us_570ea9d6e4b03d8b7b9f52aa http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/elizabeth-warren-big-ban...
- wallace_f 10y agoYes I know... I stopped reading Krugman. I don't know, it seemed like he used to give a shit and write informatively. Now he just tows the party line and even seems disingenuous at times to be honest.
- lostlogin 10y agoI think the saying is "toes the line", although I could be mistaken.
- eutectic 10y ago
- YZF 10y agoMany years ago I was chatting with a friend who is an economics professor about debt. It basically boils down to a simple rule, debt that is invested in something productive is a good idea and debt that isn't isn't. Take the parable and replace the finance industry with a Casino that lets you gamble on credit. The fisherman will all stop fishing, take credit, and play the roulette. For some time their debt will keep growing but they could end up with more cash vs. fishing. As long as the Casino makes sure they are fishing enough to pay back their debt then the Casino will get richer and the fisherman will get poorer. But that's what they get for gambling. If the government steps in and says you can borrow from the Casino forever, at zero interest rate, and you never have to pay it back, why wouldn't I go play the roulette? Futures make perfect sense when the two sides to the trade are protecting themselves against complementary eventualities and are simply seeking insurance. If they each consider the cost of that insurance there's no problem and that takes into account the cut the intermediary takes. If banks are making bad loans because they know that if the loan doesn't get repaid the government will step in and save them and if it does they'll make a lot of money, that's the point where the system breaks. EDIT: Also consider that without insurance, one bad year of fishing, and everyone on the island is dead. This is not hypothetical, in the not so distance past a draught was a death sentence to entire communities. The key is IMO speculation vs. legitimate use. The government needs to step in to discourage speculation through regulation and various other policies.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- foota 10y agoEveryone on the island is dead without fish for a year regardless of insurance.
- alexmat 10y agoTaken in the broadest sense of the term, insurance could be long term food reserves or a contract with a neighboring village for assistance in times of need in exchange for premiums.
- totalZero 10y agoThe irrational and bonkers part is where that giant financial industry ceases to believe that it could be risky to lend boat money to a fisherman. It's not necessarily irrational and bonkers for there to be more money changing hands in the fishing financial industry than among fishermen themselves. By itself, what does that really mean? It doesn't mean that money is being created out of thin air. People are making bets in that system, they are loaning money and taking specific complex risks, and as a result some people will lose everything. But also, some fishermen will be able to buy a boat or survive a season of poor catch, even in situations where many fishermen experience misfortune simultaneously. The question is how it affects the community. Maybe there's a big crash and people in the island lose their livelihoods. Or maybe the very existence of their livelihoods is due to financial services that make the fishing industry large, robust, and prosperous.
- forgetsusername 10y agoBut why do you only blame the the financial industry, and not the fisherman? Everyone loses when stupid risks are taken.
- totalZero 10y agoIf you put the name of a housecat on a loan application, and someone buys a boat in the cat's name, it's kind of hard to blame the cat.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> But why do you only blame the the financial industry, and not the fisherman? Because the fisherman has no alternative. If loans are given too freely then taking the loan becomes necessary to compete in the market against competitors who do.
- josho 10y agoI suspect that the financiers will make that very same argument.
- morgante 10y agoAnd that island is called Iceland.
- quickly 10y agoThat's really interesting. It reminds of me Schiff's parable story: How An Economy Grows And Why It Crashes
- Iv 10y agoMy answer would be that any change that did not help increase the fish production was a change too far. The insurances over market over-supplies are designed to break a fundamental feature of free-market and were not installed with a central planning to counteract, so I would draw the line there. > everything created by finance industry has found some demand among fishermen Casinos and drug dealers use the same excuse. "People want our shit!" I really believe that, while it is interesting to measure economical activity by the amount of money exchanged, it should also be measured by the amount of actual "stuff" produced: MWh for energy, calories for food, etc... It is much harder to measure, but it helps notice when an economy's growth relies too much on the financial sector. I see finance a bit like the cardboard box industry: it does help and is necessary, and its activities grow when other activities grow, but it is an anomaly when it grows without the rest of the industry following it.
- daemin 10y agoSo how would you take into consideration over-fishing? Having constantly increasing production would be good for a while until it is not. There would have to be some sort of artificial limit set, either by the fishermen themselves (which would be a cartel and well, frowned upon), or by another authority on the island (which in that case would be regulation). Outside of that there would be an ever increase in fishing, until a crash in fish numbers. Though perhaps this could be the cause of the crash in the story, an absence of fish unraveled the whole economy.
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoOver supply happens because we don't have a reliable measurement of demand to base our production on. Demand has traditionally been extremely poorly estimated with slow, out of sync, paper-based processes. Now that information can be relayed instantaneously. Perhaps a smart demand system which measures current and future demands for fish based on information input directly (P2P) from the end-user to the supply network, using some sort of utility model (which would factor in diminishing returns per user), could keep demand and supply in better balance.
- Iv 10y ago
- barnacs 10y agoThe irrational step is when people start to believe that they need money, when in fact they need fish. When people start to believe that they need loans, when in fact they need nets and boats. In the end, they deem this made up number called GDP more important than fish and hunger. See, with fish, it's obvious that catching more than the community needs to survive and piling it up in one's basement is wasteful and counter-productive. Yet, with money, not only does it seem like a good idea but it quickly becomes the ultimate goal of the participants. Money (especially with positive interest rates) is a terrible abstraction of value.
- delackner 10y agoThis is the most spot on comment in the whole discussion. We have become so utterly focused on the specifics of lending rules and incentives, yet the biggest problem is more simple: there are not actually enough homes available to house all the people that want to buy a home to live in. There would be no housing crisis if we had a regulatory environment that encouraged the housing market to produce enough homes to actually meet demand, at prices people can afford. That means smaller individual spaces (be they single family or multi-family buildings, built with vastly more automated processes, and streamlined permitting and approval processes. It is mind-boggling that today that in a major city today in the US a working person should have to pay 30+ years of income just to afford a space to sleep. Travel a little to actual first world countries and it is not hard to find places with far more sane balance of housing construction to population, with prices at far lower multiples of average income.
- hammock 10y agoAssuming this island is a closed system (it is an island after all), where did the initial lender with the capital and the "other wealthy islanders" come from?
- ionised 10y ago> the said finance person offloads the loans in a securitized fashion to other wealthy islanders who then benefit from fishing booms and receive below average returns in years that are dry. This part. This was the part that was fucking bonkers.