2 ms·
> Listing a numeric offset can't possibly be any kind of legal risk Theoretically, if the code also for some reason needed to contain the original byte-value o
by derefr 10y ago
> Listing a numeric offset can't possibly be any kind of legal risk
Theoretically, if the code also for some reason needed to contain the original byte-value of the address at that offset, you could be sued for copyright-infringing reproduction ("you published one byte of the game ROM!") Encryption would prevent this being a clear reproduction.
One could then argue, given that, that when it's trivial to deduce what the original value would have been given what the code does, you still have published a reproduction. E.g., if a code XXXXXX:YY means "give a player 0xYY lives at the start of the game", and the game regularly starts with 0x05 lives, then it's clear that byte $XXXXXX of the ROM must be 0x05.
- byuu 10y ago> Theoretically, if the code also for some reason needed to contain the original byte-value of the address at that offset The NES and Game Boy devices usually needed this. Without it, bank-switching would result in one code changing several actual ROM bytes, when you only wanted to change one. The SNES almost never used bank switching so it wasn't necessary there. Still, it's not a one-way hash function here. If you were sufficiently bored, it would be very easy to deduce the encoding for at least the :value portion of the codes, just by comparing the codes in the book. I actually did something similar as a kid. If a phrase (as in a sentence of text) were illegal, using rot13 on it wouldn't make it legal. And Nintendo were chomping at the bit to ban/outlaw/block Game Genie devices (Nintendo has a sad history of being fiercely litigious against everyone), so I'm certain they would have gone for this had they thought they stood a chance at winning. That would be one hell of a jury trial, though. "They clearly reproduced the number 5, which was in our original game! It's obviously an illegal reproduction of our copyrighted game code!"
- jandrese 10y agoNintendo did sue Galoob/Codemasters, but they lost. I have to wonder if the same trial was held today if the outcome would be the same. Copyright lawyers have really gotten quite good at convincing juries about the necessity of Copyright maximalism.