5 ms·
> Disclaimer: I work in the Q&A team at Stack Overflow. In that case, I have a serious question for you: What's your plan for refreshing the site on the long t
by user5994461 10y ago
> Disclaimer: I work in the Q&A team at Stack Overflow.
In that case, I have a serious question for you: What's your plan for refreshing the site on the long term?
Lemme explain. The "community" is actively closing new questions as "duplicate" if anything similar is already present.
At the same time, the old answer (that all duplicates are redirecting to) is often locked down for various reasons. The blocking prevents to update or add new answers.
Currently, many major questions are redirecting to one of the first answers from 3-6 years ago, when the site was relatively new. The provided answers are rotting over time.
How do you intend to prevent that?
- sklivvz1971 10y ago> How do you intend to prevent that? Very very few posts are actually uneditable at all, and editing is open to all users (some need approval). If a post is locked and outdated it's likely that the question was locked because it was the kind of question that does not provide long-lasting answers (for example a software recommendation list).
- twblalock 10y agoThat solution clearly isn't working. You need to come up with something better, or SO is going to become a graveyard of programming best practices from the year 2012.
- Mithaldu 10y ago> editing is open to all users (some need approval). Technically true, factually false, since correctness of an edit does not trump "spirit of the poster".
- winteriscoming 10y agoGiven that a voting system is in place, why not let the duplicate stay open and just mark it as a duplicate and link it to the other thread? People who don't like the new thread can down vote it and people who do want to contribute meaningful replies can still do and be upvoted if it adds value. I don't see how this might affect SEO in any bad way than the current scheme does.
- shagie 10y agoFragmentation of knowledge. The SO model tries to get the answers in one place so the people who search first find the answer in one place. If duos were open, the you'd have to look in all the places first to find the best answer. And then you might as well skip that step and ask another question rather than search. Try searching a forum or /r/javahelp or the like for an answer. See how many results you have to hit before you find an answer that works for you. Then reconsider the value of closing and pointing people at the duplicate question.
- angry_octet 10y agoSurely the better solution would be to say "This was the best answer in 2009. In 2012 there was a new answer." Also in the era of search engines, does it matter if someone compiles a point in time solution? I've lost track of the number of times I've successfully searched for that entry, only to discover it has been closed as "inappropriate". So frustrating.
- nol13 10y agoReplying to this, because on SO I don't have enough reputation to reply and say how annoying it is, or describe how the duplicate is different and/or unhelpful. I get that it's probably the only way to prevent spam comments on a large scale etc, but when see I need to ask 5 questions just to comment on the ones I care about, I don't even bother.
- gregmac 10y agoI think the stance on duplicates needs to be relaxed, with some filters/tools to help prevent higher rep users from seeing them during normal use. For example, don't show high rep users questions from low rep ones. Let other low rep users answer the question independently. It encourages participation. Let the site link duplicates together, but in a symbiotic way (even show highly voted answers from other questions as an aside.. Especially showing this on the old questions). Votes (or even higher weighting on recent votes) on the question can let the community choose which "duplicate" is best, and this can change over time.
- shagie 10y agoSo you want low rep users who don't understand the expected quality for the site to be answering questions while the high rep users who are familiar with the duplicates and expectations are prevented from helping? Preventing high rep users from answering _good_ questions from low rep users means Jon Skeet and Eric Lippert won't see them and be able to give their often spectacular answers. You're suggesting cheating low rep users who do a good job of reading the help documentation first from getting the best possible answer... and encouraging people who ask and answer poorly to continue doing so. How many more answers to How do I fix a null pointer exception in Java ( http://stackoverflow.com/questions/linked/218384?lq=1 http://stackoverflow.com/questions/linked/218384?lq=1 ) do you want to have on the site?
- gregmac 10y agoNot prevented, just not shown by default. But yes, let the low rep users answer low rep users questions. Make the site feel like it did to new users today like it did to today's high rep users five years ago. The site should discourage really obvious exact slates with suggestions.. But if someone has a small variation, let them ask it and get a specific answer. Unless the question gets many upvotes, high rep users don't see it anyway, so who does it hurt?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- user5994461 10y ago