3 ms·
Monocultures, almost by definition, encourage groups to think alike. That means the group doesn't invent anything new, and has a strong tendency to work towards
by ohjeez 10y ago
Monocultures, almost by definition, encourage groups to think alike. That means the group doesn't invent anything new, and has a strong tendency to work towards the lowest denominator. While that's sometimes valuable -- not everything needs to be revolutionary -- it does mean that true innovation is harder to achieve, because nobody is thinking outside the box. In fact, most of the team isn't even aware of the box.
Step back from the color- and gender-counting varieties of diversity for a moment, and just think of the notion of diversity itself: a variation of backgrounds and viewpoints, which can contribute to a wider view and, when done mindfully, more opportunities to serve the community (the same community that buys your products).
Surely you've had that wonderful feeling when a teammate comes up with an idea, and you respond, "Wow, what a great suggestion! I'd never have thought of that!" With attention to diversity (by which I mean, "attracting people of different viewpoints"), you encounter that sense of discovery far more often.
- rimantas 10y agoA number of things onventef ny monocultures contradict your theory.
- gaius 10y agoBut were those truly monocultures? "Diversity" as practiced in the modern sense doesn't account for age, but it wasn't always so: once upon a time experience was valued... That's a key piece that's missing from all these discussions.
- markonthewall 10y agoExcept the diversity quotas, or EEOs as they call it now, almost never allow for truly norm-bending individuals to access those roles. Having a different skin colour does not make or break group thinking. It's a mirage, at best, and a sad state of affairs for racial perception at worst. That trendy cult of diversity is only contributing to kick-start racial consciousness among white people and that fragmented society is going to blow-up in your face, down the road.
- ohjeez 10y agoFWIW I agree with you. Anything forced on a group is apt to be resented by its members, including the "token whatever" who feels that she has to represent "her kind" instead of winning or failing on her own merits. Instead, groups benefit when they themselves work to expand their own membership. It's _really_ easy for all of us to look for people who share our outlooks and opinions, a "mini me" in some way. But we grow only when we insert new ideas. I've been exceedingly lucky, in that I've worked with diverse groups of all sorts. They include people from varied backgrounds (rural vs city, money vs poor, race, gender), and in every instance I can think of a time when that "differentness" caused us to think of a better and different answer. For a lame example, someone who grew up in a rural area is more likely to think about how an online application works in a region with lousy connectivity. It's not that other team members can't think of such things, but the background ensure someone does.
- ManlyBread 10y ago>Monocultures, almost by definition, encourage groups to think alike. Why is that bad? The barriers in regards to language, religion, customs are close to non-existent and the possibilities of conflicts over gender/race dynamics are greatly lessened. The time that would otherwise be wasted on sorting out these differences can be used to perform actual work. >That means the group doesn't invent anything new Really?
- ue_ 10y agoDiversity in viewpoints, which I agree is important, does not arise from diversity in race or gender. The celebration of diversity in race or gender seems to be just for the sake of diversity. I don't know how you would select for diversity in viewpoints when hiring. But I do know that selecting for diversity in race or gender isn't a way to get there.