2 ms·
I'm not impressed by this response to some very valid criticisms. > No matter what choices we make there will be upset people. Of course no matter what you do
by shkkmo 10y ago
I'm not impressed by this response to some very valid criticisms.
> No matter what choices we make there will be upset people.
Of course no matter what you do, people will complain. This doesn't this this a valid reason to dismiss criticism out of hand without engaging with the complaints.
The correct response is to look for ways to address the very real problems that are being brought up in a way that increases the value the site provides to as many of your users as possible.
> Do we allow only english? Do we allow SO in other languages?
Make questions and answers be done in english to avoid fragmentation, but perhaps you need a community translation service to translate valuable questions and answers to other languages to increase the availability of this knowledge to those who don't speak english?
> Do we reduce moderation? Do we keep moderation as is?
Perhaps you can introduce a mechanism to sideline 'help vampire' questions, but still allow new users to build up reputation (currently very hard) by assisting with or improving those questions.
Many of SO's problems do not have simple or easy solutions, that doesn't mean that it isn't worthwhile to look for them.
- sklivvz1971 10y agoI am not dismissing anything, and I am, instead quite worried. I am sorry that you had the wrong impression. What I meant to say is that handling such a large site is like playing whack-a-mole. Seeing problems popping up is not a symptom of decline. Is a symptom of size.
- shkkmo 10y agoAh, thanks for the clarification. The site itself may not be in decline, but I am worried it may head the same direction as Wikipedia (successful, but losing active contributors.)
- WhitneyLand 10y agoI hope you're learning some lessons here. When addressing a group of your users who have concerns: 1) Never start out saying "What you don't understand is...". Instead try "Here are some of the challenges we face..." 2) Never say "Im sorry you had the wrong impression...". Instead try "I'm sorry if I miscommunicated..." I know you are not the PR guy. And it's nice you are here because people do appreciate staff commenting. Just trying to help you get a better reaction.