3 ms·
I presume you mean this: "In a more recent series of analyses, Levitt4 and Dubner and Levitt11 used FARS data from 1975 to 2003 and, by various methods, direct
by mcguire 10y ago
I presume you mean this:
"In a more recent series of analyses, Levitt4 and Dubner and Levitt11 used FARS data from 1975 to 2003 and, by various methods, directly compared the mortality with child restraint systems vs seat belts in children aged 2 to 6 years and could not demonstrate a difference in effectiveness. Levitt and Porter12 restricted the FARS data set to 2-vehicle crashes in which someone in the other vehicle (ie, the vehicle without the index child occupant) died, under the assumption that the distribution of restraint use among children in potentially fatal crashes is independent of whether someone in the other vehicle dies, after adjusting for various crash-related characteristics.
"The precision of these previous effectiveness estimates and their relevance to today's fleet were limited by their reliance on FARS (the limits of which were presented in the introduction), by the inclusion of older vehicles and restraints, and by failing to control for the severity (potential unsurvivability) of the crashes. Our analysis based on a modern cohort of children involved in crashes in which the car was rendered undrivable addressed many of the limitations of these previous analyses and found effectiveness estimates for child restraint systems to be greater than that for seat belts alone, with estimates greater than those of both Levitt4 and Hertz.6"
Levitt, et al, used only FARS data, which only records fatal accidents. A hypothetical accident where only the child would have died but that was prevented by the restraints would therefore not show up in the data, leading to the value of the restraints being under reported.
Further, failing to control for the severity of the accident (which this work does using the survival of the driver) also undervalues restraints: if the car ends up as a ball the size of a grapefruit, it doesn't matter what restraints were used.
- mhuffman 10y agoCorrect. > Levitt, et al, used only FARS data, which only records fatal accidents. A hypothetical accident where only the child would have died but that was prevented by the restraints would therefore not show up in the data, leading to the value of the restraints being under reported. This is the same regarding any type of restraints, including seat belts, no? Also, you should realized that all of their extrapolated data is also hypothetical, and relies on spotty reporting from police. Please note, that I am not convinced that Levitt has it right, just that he is not incorrect regarding the data.