3 ms·
You have to consider both sides of the equation, though. You have to consider that the cop is a human being in the heat of the moment, who wants to survive ever
by jerf 10y ago
You have to consider both sides of the equation, though. You have to consider that the cop is a human being in the heat of the moment, who wants to survive every encounter they have in the course of their career (they're not just playing the odds in this one, they're playing them all), and whom society would also like to survive.
If you overspecify caution and requirements for the cop, you'll end up in a situation we are quite arguably already starting to see in some places, where it becomes impossible to be an effective police force at all, and crime starts going up very quickly [1]. And now even more people are dead, as well as communities, and hope for the future, and all the other things like that. And this almost instantly turns out to be even worse than anything the cops ever did; we go from once-every-few-years news stories about police in a given city shooting a guy in dubious circumstances (that often, a couple of weeks later, turn out to be fairly justified, but that news story doesn't get around anything like the first one did) to "yup, another day of 10 more murders than we had per day last year". Hardly strikes me as a win.
[1]: http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2016/0402/Chicago-violent-crime-has-soared-in-2016.-What-s-the-response http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2016/0402/Chicago-viole... - and I should point out to many of you that while you politically filter that story, please note everyone involved is a Democrat.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe typical police officer never discharges their weapon in the line of duty. Here's an example. New York City has 35,000 uniformed officers. In a given year, they have ~100 incidents involving use of firearms. So even over a 30 year period ("a career"), only a smaller portion of the force will have cause to discharge their weapon (multiple 10,000s of officers over 30 years, ballpark 5,000 incidents, so a single 10,000 ballpark of involved officers). http://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/downloads/pdf/analysis_and_planning/nypd_annual_firearms_discharge_report_2011.pdf http://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/downloads/pdf/analysis_and_plan... To be clear, that includes all incidents, so if they shoot a dog or whatever, that's in there.