4 ms·
Even before the arrival of social media, the mass media was feeding people stories about the world which made it look far more dangerous than it actually was. S
by apatters 10y ago
Even before the arrival of social media, the mass media was feeding people stories about the world which made it look far more dangerous than it actually was. So media isn't the reason.
The reason is that the majority political philosophy in the US has shifted from libertarianism/classical liberalism to progressivism. The libertarian point of view is that people generally should be free to go about their own business in the manner they see fit. The progressive point of view is that we have a collective responsibility to police the wrongdoing of other people and fix it, using state power if necessary.
In the video where the guy goes off at the mother for leaving her kid in the car, you can see the progressive power dynamic in play immediately. The guy thinks she's doing something wrong so he gets involved. (Who is he? Doesn't matter. It's everyone's job to right wrongs.) It takes maybe 15 seconds before someone mentions the police, because the only way such intrusive activism works is when a higher power (can be state, law, society, science, God, whatever) is used to identify and enforce a definition of what's right. Even though the activist doesn't explicitly threaten to call the cops, during the confrontation they are mentioned constantly because the threat of state power is the only reason the mother even has to give this guy the time of day.
If you want to go a level deeper and ask why this political shift has occurred, it's likely that one contributing factor is urbanization which been underway in the US for some time--historically densely populated cities tend to be more authoritarian than rural areas because a crazy person can do more damage in a dense city (you don't see mass shootings happening in cornfields).
- fma 10y agoI agree with most points, except for the urbanization part. I don't know if you refer specifically to the US or a general human behavior. But in Asia, children still go home by themselves, play by themselves and stay at home by themselves. The cities in Asia are much more dense than in the US.
- cderwin 10y ago> If you want to go a level deeper and ask why this political shift has occurred, it's likely that one contributing factor is urbanization which been underway in the US for some time He was saying America has become more progressive because of urbanization, not that urbanization directly caused the intense scrutiny on child rearing. However I am left in want about what makes the US different than other places with regard to child rearing, even though I largely agree with the points above (though I might include authoritarianism with progressivism).
- kalleboo 10y agoIf progressivism is at fault, why aren't we seeing this problem in countries that are far more progressive?
- apatters 10y agoThat would depend on which country you're talking about. I think some countries like Sweden get away with being more progressive because they're more homogeneous. People in these countries have fewer differences of opinion and a higher level of social trust in general.