5 ms·
There's jobs for people who work hard. The vast majority of people don't want to do the hard work required to get a job. A sense of entitlement for a job won't
by andrewstuart 10y ago
There's jobs for people who work hard. The vast majority of people don't want to do the hard work required to get a job.
A sense of entitlement for a job won't lead to anything except sitting at home playing video games wondering why no one has recognised the game players genius.
It's easy to overcome lack of experience - at least in the field of software development - by using your time not playing computer games but by programming and writing code for a well-known open source project. People don't want to hear this advice though - they want to know if there is an easier way.
- fjjrxcbdhx 10y ago>There's jobs for people who work hard. So let's think this tautology through. It's difficult to get a job -> person is not able to get employment -> person becomes unemployed -> only lazy people are unemployed -> lazy people don't want jobs -> therefore everyone is employed
- andrewstuart 10y agoYou can make my words say that if you want.
- fjjrxcbdhx 10y agoIt's an empty statement because as long as anyone is employed, there will still be "enough jobs for people who work hard." It doesn't matter if there's 99.999% unemployment, since working hard by your definition is circularly referenced to already having a job. The word for that is a tautology.
- ethanbond 10y agoI think people want to know why there's no longer an easier way. It seems people 50 years ago didn't have to dedicate their waking hours from 6 to 18 years old constructing an impressive enough resume to give them the luxury of then dumping a hundred thousand dollars on an employable education. Software has an obscenely low bar for getting experience, you're right. Software comprises enough job vacancies to employ the country? The simple fact is that the system is obviously broken, and it should be just as obvious that it wasn't broke by the people who weren't yet born when it fell apart. I'll tell you, I'm a pretty hard worker. I work nowhere near as hard as the laborers down the street who go day in day out being told this incoherent narrative of "just work harder and it'll pay off!" There's no reason to believe that it will. Why wouldn't they just do bare minimum and go home and play video games?
- andrewstuart 10y agoI only know employment in IT. I have no doubt that people in other sectors, particularly blue collar, have it much harder.
- internaut 10y agoIt is normal for blue collar workers to make 2x - 4x more than white collar workers today. This is in my area so things may be different elsewhere. Kids don't want to go into blue collar work because it is looked down upon as a 'lack of advancement' or similar middle class trope.
- ethanbond 10y agoUh it might be normal for some. And by some I mean highly skilled unionized workers. Let's not forget the millions of blue collar workers who had their jobs disappear overnight in the past 15 years. Many of these people showed loyalty to their employers for spans of several decades. Of course, loyalty plays no role in the calculus of capitalism. You think a kid should aspire to a blue collar job right after an entire generation of blue collar workers were laid off at the stroke of a pen? Right when every other post on the front page of HN carries foreboding of an automation job-pocalypse just a decade after an outsourcing job-pocalypse? You're a maniac. Anyone capable of evaluating these options with an ounce of foresight is going to take the gamble on college and make a desperate debt-ridden attempt to scramble to the top of the knowledge economy. The only economy that isn't demonstrably under threat.
- internaut 10y ago> Uh it might be normal for some. And by some I mean highly skilled unionized workers. Some clarification. I do blue collar and white collar work myself. Not in America, not a member of a union. I don't think most blue collar workers I know are in unions, maybe some of the electricians but that is probably it. I don't think they need one either, it is a kind of hold-over. I code (for my projects, some of which spin money as well as independent work) and also do things like cleaning, plastering etc. I make a good deal more money this way in my situation. For the sake of a comparison, I usually earn at least $30-40 per hour in blue collar activity, often more, but the payments for code tend to be highly variable. I prefer to choose jobs I find personally enjoyable or those with objectives I support, which is a freedom I value a lot. I probably make about the same or less if you averaged out everything, but it is not entirely about economics. I also don't like to make a sharp distinction between the different things I do for a living. I think that is a old fashioned way of thinking. I've gotten software work from blue collar jobs and blue collar jobs from software work I've done. I actually think the pay is higher this way. > Let's not forget the millions of blue collar workers who had their jobs disappear overnight in the past 15 years. Many of these people showed loyalty to their employers for spans of several decades. Of course, loyalty plays no role in the calculus of capitalism. We should make a distinction between factory labour (which I agree has had serious job reductions over time) and the trades, which have done quite well over time and are relatively prosperous in real terms. I think this is also true in the USA judging from what I've heard. > You think a kid should aspire to a blue collar job right after an entire generation of blue collar workers were laid off at the stroke of a pen? Right when every other post on the front page of HN carries foreboding of an automation job-pocalypse just a decade after an outsourcing job-pocalypse? I have a computer science degree from a red brick university. I think I know about automation and AI. I have read Norvig/Russell's book from cover to cover a couple of times. It is like this: If your job is very routine, it was or is being automated by machines with an extreme division of labour. That is the history of the past few centuries. If your job is routine and information-centric, then it was or is being automated by computer programmers like myself. That is the history of the past few decades. If however your job falls into three categories: 1. Information-centric and novel. e.g. starting your own company with software skills, or even a job in the entertainment industry. 2. People-centric jobs, like being a host, gym trainer or prostitute. 3. Skilled labour. Skilled labour is almost always novel. Tadelakt finishes or custom cabinetry is not about to be automated. You know why? Because people want authenticity. It is like the economy of the neo-victorians in The Diamond Age. People who buy furniture from IKEA are not the rich of society. Machine made = stuff normal people can buy = not elite = not fashionable. Machine production is too orderly, too linear. This is not theoretical. I've ordered a bunch of jobs done that I could have gotten cheaper if I chose the automated option but I don't want to. This is a phenomenon I see everywhere. > You're a maniac. Anyone capable of evaluating these options with an ounce of foresight is going to take the gamble on college and make a desperate debt-ridden attempt to scramble to the top of the knowledge economy. The only economy that isn't demonstrably under threat. We just don't see the same world. In fact it is much worse than you think, because I don't even agree our society is becoming more technologically advanced. It is in computation, and computation related fields. Which is a lot. But it is not everything. Energy prices are exponentially higher than they were in the 1970s. Silicon Valley is not powerful enough to lift up the entire economy. Not even close! Ex-computation, there has been very little technological growth for the last few decades. There's a few bright spots, like fracking and solar but huge parts of the economy have not seen technological or economic progress for half a lifetime. You can think I'm a manic if you want, but Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, Larry Summers and Larry Page all agree with me on this. An Edit: Just to be clear. We probably agree wages are stuck for the average person (look at my other posts), and that opportunities are dimming. The difference is that you believe automation to be the cause, but I am saying the exact opposite, that it is actually a lack of general development that is causing joblessness and wage stagnation. One of us has to be wrong!