15 ms·
Is Cheese Rational? (2012)
- douche 10y agoI have to wonder what was going through the mind of the first person who stored some milk in a sheep's stomach, waited a few days, and decided, "Hey, this coagulated mess looks like something I'd like to eat"
- smallnamespace 10y agoThey might have been starving at the time.
- evilduck 10y agoThousand-year eggs? Stinkheads? Casu Marzu? Hakari? I'm pretty sure all of these were a starving person digging up their old trash, looking at it and making a hard decision.
- M_Grey 10y agoNot even that hard a decision if you're starving, especially when it doesn't make you crap liquid and die.
- evilduck 10y agoThe first person to discover their edibility would not have known if they were about to crap liquid until they died when they ate it, but they likely would have known that in general rotten food can make you ill, hence the hard decision, chancing survival against a potentially earlier death.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe fact that any of us are here to have this chat leads me to believe that the basic principles of testing edibility have been handed down since antiquity. Smell it. "Oh that's rank! Yet, I am starving." Touch it to your lips. "They're not numb! Result." Touch it to your tongue. "No burning, no numbness, no tingling, good!" Eat a very little bit, "Tastes better than I'd have thought." Wait. "I'm alive, and I feel a very little bit less hungry!" Eat some more. "I'm not hungry, I don't have dysentery, and I can still see."
- danharaj 10y agoNot to mention the permutations a human living in subsistence conditions would try. What if I cook it? What if I dry it? What if I soak it for a while? And so and and so forth.
- M_Grey 10y agoDefinitely. Especially anytime that food was likely to spoil rapidly and was incredibly valuable, like dairy. It also explains things like pemmican, which clearly evolved from a, "What if I add some berries and pound the ever loving crap out of it?" experimental lineage.
- Zancarius 10y agoI'd imagine it's also influenced by our stomach acid which plays a pretty substantial part in killing off most of the nasty things that could make us ill, although most of those same nasty things have defensive mechanisms that can help them survive the initial onslaught of the acid (high protein foods seem to provide some refuge [1]). Your comment reminded me of a YouTube channel I find weirdly (perhaps morbidly) fascinating [2]. Once your body is acclimated to eating dubious quality materials, even in modern society, it seems that you're less likely to get sick provided you're still relatively careful (not that I'd recommend it). Steve1989 has gotten sick from his adventures, although surprisingly it was from a more recent Ukranian MRE contaminated with E. coli, and not from some of the more expected sources. It's worth watching a few of his videos if you can stomach it, if not for the surprise at what questionable materials he actually gets down, but for the unusual number and types of things that have survived (he's eaten a cookie from 1951, 61 year old peanut butter, and even Civil War era hardtack). I guess my memory was triggered by your mention of numb lips. As I understand it from the channel above, rancid nuts are particularly bad at causing numbness and swelling. I certainly wouldn't recommend trying anything of the sort unless you were absolutely desperate! Definitely check out his channel. It's gross, I'll warn you, but it's also fascinating. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC106573/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC106573/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2I6Et1JkidnnbWgJFiMeHA/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2I6Et1JkidnnbWgJFiMeHA/vid...
- mannykannot 10y agoCheese is more than just tolerable: by reducing the amount of lactose present, it turns milk into a food for lactose-intolerant adults. It is thought that adult lactose intolerance was the primal state of humanity, and that cheese consumption was a step on the way to adult tolerance, in those cultures that developed it. http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v493/n7433/abs/nature11698.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v493/n7433/abs/nature11...
- hyperpallium 10y agoYes, and lactose tolerance in adulthood seems to have evolved quite recently (7000 BC IIRC). Of course, human infants are already lactose tolerant (so they can suckle). I'm guessing the switch-off evolvee for involuntary weening, and had survival value. I believe bread, beer and wine pre-date cheese, and so the idea of a transformation through some agent wasn't that far-fetched. And milk obviously is nutritous. I'm not sure, but can you make sorta cheese, in the way that rotting fruit is natural fermentation, and dough can rise from wild-yeast (and unlevened bread was being eaten already). Once the idea is born, you can work to improve it. It's easy to think of primitive humans as dummies, but they were probably smarter than most of us, and once they got an idea, they would tweak it. Plus, it only takes one clever and lucky person in a network of communities to hit on an improvement, for it to spread. But there's a question of why the lactose tolerant mutation spread so widely... was there a starvation event? An outcompeting, or invasion by stronger, milk-fed warriors? But I expect cheese making eating was very wide-spread well before this event, and it was a great source of calories. Blessed are the cheese makers.
- masklinn 10y ago> But there's a question of why the lactose tolerant mutation spread so widely... was there a starvation event? An outcompeting, or invasion by stronger, milk-fed warriors? It seems calorical contribution was the main factor in sub-saharan africa but in europe (the other main source of the mutation) it is mostly linked to vitamin D deficiency (the mutation spread from areas with less sun, especially inland areas with limited access to fish).
- deleted 10y ago
- bitJericho 10y agoNot even starving. Look up ashens on YouTube. Maybe it was just for kicks.
- fridek 10y agoProbably they made a waterbag from the stomach and stored milk in it.
- strommen 10y agoI have to wonder what was going through the mind of somebody who selected the username "douche".
- mundo 10y agoIt means "shower" in French.
- kaffeemitsahne 10y agoPeople weren't always such wimps as we are today :-)
- danieltillett 10y agoYou don’t have to wait a few days for rennet to work. It will coagulate the milk in minutes. In the past when everyone lived on the edge of starvation you could not be so fussy in what you ate. If you really want to see what starvation will make people eat take a look (from a great distance and upwind) at Hákarl [1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hákarl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hákarl
- kough 10y agoI tried this – on a visit to Iceland, my (older) family friend / impromptu tour guide made me and my traveling companions taste it. The young Icelandic locals in the rest area laughed their asses off and snapchatted the whole thing, because "no one eats that anymore, it's for old people obsessed with traditions." Makes sense, it was truly disgusting. The Hvalspik (https://guidetoiceland.is/history-culture/the-worlds-most-disgusting-icelandic-food https://guidetoiceland.is/history-culture/the-worlds-most-di...) really was quite interesting though.
- danieltillett 10y agoSome traditions deserve to die. Another one that I will not be sad to see go the way of the dodo is Surströmming [1]. I love the quote from Wolfgang Fassbender "the biggest challenge when eating surströmming is to vomit only after the first bite, as opposed to before”. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surströmming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surströmming
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 10y ago>If you really want to see what starvation will make people eat Apart from the smell, this is not different from tons of other cured meats, salami, beef jerky etc (actually, beef jerky doesn't smell that nice, either). More of a cultural thing than starvation? Especially since Icelanders are pretty well off, and as far from starvation as possible and still eat it...
- M_Grey 10y agoThe answer is the same as the people who gave oysters or crabs a try... when you're starving you'll try literally anything. When it doesn't turn out to be toxic, or make you feel ill, that's something you stick with. Something like cheese is even better, since you can turn a wasted surplus into portable, stored calories.
- danharaj 10y agoI am skeptical of all of the replies so far implying that the threat of imminent starvation is what drove people to discover weird foods. We're intelligent omnivores, we like finding and trying new foods. Finding as many food sources as possible is one of the essential tasks of a group of humans living in subsistence conditions. Note the distinction between subsistence and starvation. What went through their mind? Perhaps that milk spoils way too quickly and food that you can store for long periods of time is vital for survival. They probably would have known a great deal about the preparation and preservation of food in general, like the use of fire or that drying and covering food makes it last much longer. Their tolerance for food with strong unpleasant flavors would have been much higher than yours or mine and they would have had knowledge on how to test potentially dangerous substances to see how edible they are. If you stored milk in a stomach, it would coagulate very quickly. The substance would be solid: something you can dry! Aha. This could be a good way to store surplus milk. Early homo sapiens were pretty smart and had skills few of us today possess.
- nerdponx 10y agoWell, that and the fact that fresh cheese actually smells nice. I think a lot of the people replying here are thinking "yogurt" when they ought to be thinking "fresh farmers cheese."
- radicaldreamer 10y agoExactly, it would be odd if early humans were less creative than today. The main difference seems to be infrastructure and they didn't have the positive feedback englightment loops the developed world does today.
- 13of40 10y ago> If you stored milk in a stomach, it would coagulate very quickly. The substance would be solid: something you can dry! Aha. This could be a good way to store surplus milk. You can make cheese without any sheep stomach involved, so it was probably more of an "Ah ha! Faster cheese!" sort of moment.
- 10y ago
- pmoriarty 10y agoI suspect a lot of substances we now know to be edible were first tested on prisoners.
- ars 10y agoThey didn't really keep prisoners back then, certainly not for long periods of time. Jailing someone is a relatively modern invention, back then they preferred corporal punishment (lashing most often).
- pmoriarty 10y agoWhat about slaves?
- ars 10y agoSlaves they had, but were far too valuable to use for testing things like this. Only kings and such could afford to waste salves that way. And anyone rich enough to have slaves probably did not need to test random foods since they already had what they needed. War captives maybe, or those condemned to die, but those are state things, and the state is unlikely to need to test foods. They most likely used animals, same as we do today. Dogs would be my guess.
- ruricolist 10y agoIt's more probable that the original was a goat: "Upon killing a kid, a farmer simply takes its milk-filled stomach, ties it off in a tight knot or sews it shut, perhaps covers it in mesh to keep the flies off, then hangs it from the ceiling of a cool, dark room. He then waits for a few months until the natural rennet within curdles and hardens the milk into a thick, creamy cheese..." http://roadsandkingdoms.com/2015/the-secret-life-of-cheese/ http://roadsandkingdoms.com/2015/the-secret-life-of-cheese/
- M_Grey 10y agoWhen you know virtually nothing accurate about how the world works, anything can be a source of wonder and irrationality; that's my takeaway from the quoted portions of that manuscript.
- sandworm101 10y agoIs eating cheese rational? I'm reminded of a statement by Jeremy Clarkson about the possibility of nutritional warning labels on cheese. Without substantial nutritional value[1], being essentially just calories, the rational decision is to not eat it. But we do. His point was that if things like soda (Coke) is going to be labelled or taxed as unhealthy, why not cheese? For some historical or cultural reason why see cheese as something wholesome or "natural". Is is? It seems to me more a trick of chemistry, a means of preserving caloric content from a time when getting enough calories was the only concern. [1] While cheese does contain some nutrients, you have to eat piles of it to get anywhere near a recommended daily dose, by which point you've eaten far more calories than anyone would consider healthy. For below: Vitamin D in Cheese: 1oz = 2% of daily value. 100/2 = 50 oz to get your daily minimum of D from cheese. 50oz of cheese = 1.5kg = 5700 calories + bowel obstruction = Not a rational way of getting your daily Vitamin D. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-HealthProfessional/ https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-HealthProfessiona...
- jholman 10y agoCheese contains huge quantities of fat and protein, both of which are nutrients that I want to eat. What on earth do you mean by "without substantial nutritional value"? Are you of the impression that calories are bad? Listen, my doctor says that if I don't get at least a thousand calories a day, I might die.
- SwellJoe 10y agoSo...perhaps the author of this marginalia is questioning whether cheese thinks (or is alive in some sense), rather than whether making cheese is a rational pursuit? The next one "Is cheese animal, and do we eat it alive?" makes me think it's much more likely the former than the latter. That would be an interesting question, and maybe illuminating of the general knowledge about microscopic processes back then. Some cheese, of course, has bacterial cultures involved in the making of, and so some cheese is alive, by some definition. In the usual case, though, I guess it is adding acid to milk/cream and letting it coagulate into curds and then pressing it; so the answer is probably mostly no, if we assume a relatively clean environment for making and storing the cheese. But, perhaps the writer of the marginalia is wondering if it is a process like making beer, or other fermentation that is actually using live cultures (I don't know how well the "liveness" of yeast and other cultures was understood back then; though I suspect they understood it better than the average modern non-baker/non-brewer, since so many people made their own bread and beer).
- dmoo 10y agoReminds me of the debate over the liveness of a strawberry on the BBC podcast The Infinite Monkey Cage http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00snr0w/episodes/downloads http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00snr0w/episodes/downloads
- barrkel 10y ago"Some cheese"? All cheeses worth savouring are cultured. All cheddar (probably the most popular cheese globally) is cultured. The only cheeses that aren't cultured are things like uncultured mozzarella or queso fresco.
- SwellJoe 10y ago"All cheeses worth savouring are cultured." I'm rather fond of a wide variety of fresh cheeses. Paneer, and other sorts of "farmers cheese" and cottage cheese are all made with just acid curdling and aren't cultured. Most mozzarella, and many other soft cheeses, can and are made without cultures. I'm not an expert on the subject, by any means, but there's a huge variety of things we call "cheese" and they're made in a pretty wide variety of ways. More importantly might be what kinds of cheeses people were aware of and making back when this note-taker was thinking these thoughts and asking these questions about cheese. Were cultured cheeses common in his region and time? I dunno and the article doesn't reveal it. There have been times and places where "cheese" meant a fresh cheese like paneer or cottage cheese, but probably other times and places when bacterial cultures were involved in all or most cheese production. I suspect the further back we go, the more likely we are to find fresh cheeses being more common than the cultured cheeses since they were simpler to make, but I dunno. The ability to store a hard cheese without refrigeration would have been pretty valuable to pre-industrial society.
- bane 10y agoOne of the things that's most impressive about humans is that, despite needing somewhere between 1200-2000 calories per day to survive, humans have managed to not only find that number pretty much anywhere on the planet, but find enough variety to provide for all essential nutrients. For example, I was idly watching this documentary [1] and there's a point where the subject of the film ends up living with some natives of micronesia. Here's the relevant bit https://youtu.be/-qSXyz3he3M?t=899 https://youtu.be/-qSXyz3he3M?t=899 Despite living on a tiny dot of land surrounded by undrinkable liquid and virtually no major sources of fresh water. These folks have managed to find that many calories x 150 people and get enough variety to get all of their major macro and micro nutrients covered. They've been successful enough at this to have made a successful go at it for thousands of years. And if you look at the people, they're not at near starvation levels of food. And we find this everywhere on the planet, humans of the same species, managed to spread to nearly every corner of the planet thousands upon thousands of years ago survive and thrive. That's amazing. There's lots of comments that remark on what you end up eating when you're starving. But I think the pattern is in many ways the opposite. Humans have been successful everywhere they could walk, climb or get to on a boat. Most of human habitation is one of getting enough to eat most of the time, at least long enough to reproduce and raise the next generation to the point that they can feed themselves. Another point is that humans have had various preservation techniques, in almost every society I know of, dating back into pre-history. The idea that you can apply a set of techniques that work one place to another makes complete sense. Cheese is likely the result of a very deliberate process and patience rather than a starving person desperately shoving anything that might have digestible calories into their mouth. 1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qSXyz3he3M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qSXyz3he3M
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Houshalter 10y agoCheese is a way of making milk edible. Before cheese humans couldnt digest milk. Someone let a bunch of useless milk set out and realized the result was pretty tasty, hence we have cheese.
- 205guy 10y agoIt seems to me that both the manuscript and its annotations are being entirely misinterpreted by the other commenters here. It doesn't help that the article in question is giving so few details or context. Near as I can tell, the manuscript is creating some sort of allegory whereby a creator god (in this case that of Christianity) creates humanity, to be compared with the way that humans create or make cheese. In that context, the "is cheese rational?" annotation is expressing doubt at the validity of the comparison, by pointing out that the distinguishing feature of humans is their ability to think (to reason or be rational). The second annotation about cheese being animal and eaten seems to further criticize the comparison by pointing out that human is to cheese not as creator is to humanity. At least without some deep theological background into the time and place of the writings, that would be my interpretation.