4 ms·
Diversity fatigue
- hprotagonist 10y agotl;dr: human resources ruins everything.
- donatj 10y agoArguably the tl;dr for the entire corporate world.
- aboonaboo 10y agoDiversity in and of itself is not inherently good. That is a fact
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thescribe 10y ago> The growing diversity of the workforce should be a cause for celebration. Why? What makes this inherently better than say, a monocultural group like Japan.
- jdale27 10y agoThe author addresses this in the second and third paragraphs of the article.
- x1798DE 10y agoMost of the second paragraph is devoted to the fact that the talent base is becoming more diverse. That does not make diversity itself inherently valuable, it just means that it's a disadvantage to restrict yourself to a monoculture. The part about workplaces with more female executives being more profitable is weak evidence for the inherent value of diversity because it could easily be driven by the above effect or any number of other factors.
- icegreentea 10y agoOk, maybe the second paragraph is kinda bunk, but there's still good stuff in the third paragraph. I mean, the question is 'diversity in the workplace' in western nations pretty much comes down to asking the questions of 'why should your workplace not roughly reflect your hiring pool' and 'why should your hiring pool not roughly reflect your demographics'. There can be good reasons for why either may not the case for specific instances, but unless you can give a good reason, then you're either actively screwing people over, or participating in some sort of systemic activity that's screwing people over.
- x1798DE 10y agoYes, agreed about the third paragraph. I think the question about diversity, though, often comes down to "why should you prioritize diversity over other factors", not "why should you not avoid hiring blacks/women etc". I think generally the debate now is about whether a "blind" hiring process would be better than a "diversity-aware" hiring process, where you are actively shooting for a culturally/ethnically/gender diverse team, and about how much "diversity" counts for vs. skill (i.e. person A is a better programmer than person B, but person A is white/straight/male and person B is black/gay/female - how much better than B does A have to be that his value outweighs the diversity value of hiring B).
- fatalogic 10y agoImo it's better because you have a different set of eyes and perspectives looking at a problem so you don't have issues the Kodak issue of the 70s or the recent google image search issues. A more diverse workforce may have caught these issues before they hit production. You can't see problems if you don't know they exist. http://petapixel.com/2015/09/19/heres-a-look-at-how-color-film-was-originally-biased-toward-white-people/ http://petapixel.com/2015/09/19/heres-a-look-at-how-color-fi... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/06/10/google-faulted-for-racial-bias-in-image-search-results-for-black-teenagers/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/06/1...
- bewo001 10y agoA real-world example: we were in negotiations about a big project with a vendor. We - a team of guys about the same age - had a lot of issues with the technical solution the vendor proposed. The next day they brought in a very attractive blonde engineer, and my useless straight colleagues would be gazing at her legs rather than asking tough technical questions. The vendor wouldn't have tried this if we had some women on the team.
- ManlyBread 10y agoAll this really means is that your colleagues are unprofessional and/or incompetent. There's a zero guarantee that having women on your team would prevent them from doing that.
- gjolund 10y agoIt sounds like your colleagues are just a bunch of amateurs.
- kingmanaz 10y agoWar is peace. Freedom is slavery. Diversity is strength.
- gaius 10y agoThere is a saying that you can only manage what you can measure, but the problem is then, you only manage what you can easily measure. It's easy to tick boxes for gender, sexuality, race etc - but if everyone you hire is a 20-something graduate of the same top 10 universities, from the same socio-economic class, having sat in the same lectures, read the same books, been exposed to all the same ideas, buys the same brands, has the same hobbies, then how can the benefits of diversity be realized? I believe nearly every high-profile product flop from major tech firms can be attributed to this.
- koder2016 10y ago"We increased diversity in IT!" "Cool, you hired a dynamic Python dev, a static functional Haskel dev and a UX inclined HTML/C# dev?" "Err... No, we hired a cartesian product of races and genders within Java skillset... But they sure have different worldviews!"
- sattoshi 10y agoWhy does everybody keep saying that diversity is a good thing? I'm not arguing it's a bad thing.. but why is it a bad thing? The most notable thing I see in diversity are additional language and cultural barriers that will slow down productivity.
- ohjeez 10y agoMonocultures, almost by definition, encourage groups to think alike. That means the group doesn't invent anything new, and has a strong tendency to work towards the lowest denominator. While that's sometimes valuable -- not everything needs to be revolutionary -- it does mean that true innovation is harder to achieve, because nobody is thinking outside the box. In fact, most of the team isn't even aware of the box. Step back from the color- and gender-counting varieties of diversity for a moment, and just think of the notion of diversity itself: a variation of backgrounds and viewpoints, which can contribute to a wider view and, when done mindfully, more opportunities to serve the community (the same community that buys your products). Surely you've had that wonderful feeling when a teammate comes up with an idea, and you respond, "Wow, what a great suggestion! I'd never have thought of that!" With attention to diversity (by which I mean, "attracting people of different viewpoints"), you encounter that sense of discovery far more often.
- rimantas 10y agoA number of things onventef ny monocultures contradict your theory.
- gaius 10y agoBut were those truly monocultures? "Diversity" as practiced in the modern sense doesn't account for age, but it wasn't always so: once upon a time experience was valued... That's a key piece that's missing from all these discussions.
- markonthewall 10y agoExcept the diversity quotas, or EEOs as they call it now, almost never allow for truly norm-bending individuals to access those roles. Having a different skin colour does not make or break group thinking. It's a mirage, at best, and a sad state of affairs for racial perception at worst. That trendy cult of diversity is only contributing to kick-start racial consciousness among white people and that fragmented society is going to blow-up in your face, down the road.