3 ms·
> I don't think anyone seriously believes that Android doesn't make money. Why else would Google put so much money into it in the first place? There is a diffe
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> I don't think anyone seriously believes that Android doesn't make money. Why else would Google put so much money into it in the first place?
There is a difference between making money from something and making money as a result of it.
Imagine Android was made by Mozilla. Then Oracle would have to be litigating against Mozilla and Mozilla's profits would be zero dollars because Android is free.
Meanwhile Google would still be making billions of dollars "from" Android in the same way they make billions of dollars "from" iOS.
Android is better for them because Apple controls iOS and can use that control to extract concessions or money from Google. So you would be entirely unsurprised if you learned that Google had cut Mozilla a big donation check. But that doesn't mean Google should owe Oracle money -- if there was no Android then more of Google's customers would have iOS (or something else) instead, and possibly more of Google's revenue would be going go Apple, but still none of it would have gone to Oracle.
- euyyn 10y agoI imagine Oracle's argument isn't "if there was no Android", rather "Google is so economically interested in Android existing, that they would have paid us a license for the API copyright".
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> I imagine Oracle's argument isn't "if there was no Android", rather "Google is so economically interested in Android existing, that they would have paid us a license for the API copyright". More likely they would have just not used the API, as Apple has done this whole time.
- euyyn 10y agoI'm only saying that's their argument.
- tamana 10y agoHmm. Suppose I want to buy a bike. Joe steals a bike and sells it to me for cheap. I did nothing wrong, but could be forced to return the bike. But if I resell the bike, I am no longer liable?
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoIf you resell stolen property, the police will take it from whoever ends up in possession of it and then everyone who bought it will each in turn end up looking to their seller for a refund. But that analogy doesn't fit at all. It's more like what happens if someone steals a bike and while riding around on it sees a billboard which leads to profit for the advertiser. Are you saying the advertiser now owes the bike owner something?