3 ms·
It's well understood, I think, that the biggest determiner of what search engine people use is the default one put in front of them. That's why Google's willing
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
It's well understood, I think, that the biggest determiner of what search engine people use is the default one put in front of them. That's why Google's willing to spend a billion dollars to be that default. Google's claims to it's antimonopoly position often hinges on the claim that it's a 'natural' monopoly, created simply by the fact that they have the best product. It's unsurprising, then, that they're so angry that this lawyer revealed Google pays so much to ensure their dominance.
Google has long held that Android is something like a charity project, to "ensure an open future for mobile" or something like that. You can still see signs of it in the terms of the "Open Handset Alliance", which is actually the group of manufacturers Google forbids from using open source Android, ironically. It's also commonly the defense for why Google isn't a monopoly here: It "gives Android away for free". In reality, Google collects billions in profit, and leaves all of the software patching and support burdens on manufacturers, who can barely turn a profit and are held to Google's increasingly controlling mandates over how Android must be distributed. (I'm sure many OEMs after this case are curious why they're getting such a raw deal on Android, which is another reason it's unsurprising Google is so angry at Oracle.)
- Grazester 10y agoWhose fault is it that manufacturers cant turn a profit? Is Google suppose to give a handout to them when it gives them the source code to Android? Google provides the patch for the software. It is up the manufacturers to get it to their phones. Google is being the responsible one here if you ask me. Its the manufacture not providing support for their product who is at fault here.
- tracker1 10y agoWhich is why they started down the path around 5.0 to separate as much in application space from the lower kernel space as they can... the browser is now a separate chrome (preinstalled) instead of built in, etc... so that they can actually update the apps without device maker approval.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoSo many lies. Google does not "forbid" their OEM partners from using open source Android. What they forbid is that a member of the OHA cannot create a fork of Android that breaks the CTS. If you want to do so then you're free to leave the OHA and create your own version. As for your search engine theory, well, that's also incorrect. The default search engine on Windows is bing - in fact it's baked into the OS and cannot even be turned off. The default search engine on their browser is also bing. So it would seem people are going out of their way to either download Chrome and use Google as their default search engine or modify the default search engine in Windows to use Google.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoIt's also worth noting that a pure, pro-bono open source project would still likely be interested in such a provision to help ward off an embrace-extend-extinguish scenario by controlling access to the trademark.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoIt's interesting that that's so well understood, when Windows (which had the majority of the consumer internet-connected device market share even if you include smartphones for most of Google's history) never defaulted to Google search.