5 ms·
A good overview of the situation. The slow erosion of freedoms is coming earlier than expected. Fortunately, the HK people recognise the salami tactics of the
by FabHK 10y ago
A good overview of the situation. The slow erosion of freedoms is coming earlier than expected.
Fortunately, the HK people recognise the salami tactics of the CCP, and protest (as in the umbrella movement 2014), and a small but growing minority now agitates for some sort of independence.
However, given
* the increasing power of China on a world-wide stage, even vis-a-vis, say, the UK
* the decreasing relevance of HK for China (see the graph in the article: HK GDP was a quarter of China GDP, now under 3%)
* China's aversion to any secession (almost instinctive, though probably based on historically justified fear of crumbling order and prosperity when a dynasty falls apart), as seen in Xinjiang, Tibet, etc.
it is hard to see how the tensions can be reduced peacefully, rather than gathering steam.
- vkou 10y agoErosion of which freedoms? For most of its modern history, Hong Kong was a dictatorship. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Hong_Kong#Government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Hong_Kong#Government > For almost all of its history under British rule, executive power in Hong Kong was concentrated in the hands of the colony governor, a position appointed by the British crown without any democratic input from Hong Kong citizens. The introduction of elected representatives determined by local elections, even limited to the role of "advisory councils", did not begin until after the 1984 agreements by the British to hand Hong Kong over to China.
- burritoburrito 10y agoControl of domestic affairs under the "one country, two systems" framework introduced at the handover. Wikipedia maintains a decent compendium on sources of tension: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong–Mainland_conflict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong–Mainland_conflict
- vinay427 10y agoPerhaps those (post-British freedoms) were the freedoms the parent comment was referring to. I don't believe he or she stated the freedoms were because of British rule.
- necessity 10y agoE.g. Hong Kong Is Banning Pro-Independence Candidates From Running in Elections http://time.com/4436253/hong-kong-election-briefing-protests-edward-leung-china-independence/ http://time.com/4436253/hong-kong-election-briefing-protests... By the way Hong Kong under British rule was freer than mainland China has ever been under the CCP rule, even though they did not have democratically elected leaders.
- vkou 10y agoThe British banned all pro-independence candidates, by not having elections. And by arresting, and occasionally killing protesters, but that's just how colonialism goes. [1] The British were quite happy to give the people of Hong Kong freedom, when it didn't cost them anything. China's current behavior is not dissimilar. Hong Kong exchanged a colonial overlord ruling from London, with one ruling from Beijing. Neither concerns themselves much with the welfare of the populace. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canton%E2%80%93Hong_Kong_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canton%E2%80%93Hong_Kong_strik...
- necessity 10y agoYou talk about "the years until 84", then talk about "arrests and murder of protesters", citing a source talking about the IXX century... That's dishonest.
- vkou 10y agoMaintaining foreign rule - by any empire - requires the use of informants, secret police, and suppression of political activity. The Birtish didn't station thousands of soldiers in Hong Kong so they could have an exotic vacation. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Forces_Overseas_Hong_Kong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Forces_Overseas_Hong_K...
- spacehunt 10y agoI'm not sure what point are you trying to make. Apart from the 1967 riots, which were orchestrated by another country anyway, when did the British Forces turn against Hong Kong people?
- FabHK 10y agoTrust me, you can have an appointed governor, yet many civil liberties and the rule of law. Conversely, you can have a "Democratic People's Republic" without either (looking at you, North Korea). Of course the UK was hypocritical in "recognising" the importance of democracy just before handing HK over to China. But that HK enjoys civil liberties and the rule of law, more so than the mainland, and has so even under British administration, particularly after WW II, is undeniable.
- pjc50 10y agoBritish HK was better for freedom of speech and rule of law, I believe. Participatory government is important but not the only factor in freedom.
- vkou 10y agoFreedom of speech is worth little, when you don't have freedom of political activity. What good is it if you can criticize your government, when you can't do anything change it? Speech, by itself, does nothing - until you transform it into action. Which was quite illegal. Inmates in a prison have as much freedom of speech as they could ever want - but they are not free.
- CountSessine 10y agoWhat good is it if you can criticize your government, when you can't do anything change it? It's not going to be too long before the people of HK can do neither, much like their pitiable neighbours to the north.
- kiba 10y agoThe government DID change. How do you think HK got non-corrupt? Trust me, it wasn't because of a democracy.
- chillacy 10y agoIt's not like HK volunteered to become a subject of the Crown in the first place though: > In 1839, Britain invaded China to crush opposition to its interference in the country’s economic and political affairs. One of Britain’s first acts of the war was to occupy Hong Kong, a sparsely inhabited island off the coast of southeast China. In 1841, China ceded the island to the British, and in 1842 the Treaty of Nanking was signed, formally ending the First Opium War. http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/hong-kong-ceded-to-the-british http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/hong-kong-ceded-t... If Canada invaded the US and forced rohde island to become a territory of Canada, I'd probably be bitter about it, even if it became safer to live there.
- 10y ago
- peteretep 10y agoYou are confusing suffrage with freedom.
- spacehunt 10y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/28/world/asia/china-began-push-against-hong-kong-elections-in-50s.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/28/world/asia/china-began-pus... > ... beginning in the 1950s, the colonial governors who ran Hong Kong repeatedly sought to introduce popular elections but abandoned those efforts in the face of pressure by Communist Party leaders in Beijing.
- necessity 10y agoChina is just as averse as any other country to secession, it only seems more oppressive about it because more people have tried to secede from it in the last decades. Brazil for instance has a history of revolts for secession, but after ten or twenty bloodbaths the people quieted down, and now only a handful timidly call for it. I'm sure other countries have a similar history, and I hope that nowadays they would have a more understanding attitude towards it. For instance, Catalonia seems to be closer than ever from seceding from Spain, and I hope they can do it without conflict. I wonder though what would happen if one day there are enough Texans to vote for a secession and enough reason to press for it if it's not legally accepted... I imagine Uncle Sam would not be very happy about it.
- FabHK 10y agoDisagree. Of course, secession is not an everyday occurrence. But Scotland had a referendum 2014 about leaving the UK, and Scottish independence can be openly discussed. Some autonomous regions of Spain enjoy big degrees of autonomy, and might get more. China is very protective of its integrity, and I'd say even more so than many, if not most countries. (I wonder, incidentally, how constitutions deal with it.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jdietrich 10y ago>Some autonomous regions of Spain enjoy big degrees of autonomy, and might get more. The Basque separatist movement hasn't been entirely peaceful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETA_(separatist_group) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETA_(separatist_group)
- Steko 10y agoThe UK wasn't the greatest example either given the not so distant history of Northern Ireland.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]