3 ms·
I think this is a terminological suggestion from SpiderOak https://spideroak.com/features/zero-knowledge https://spideroak.com/features/zero-knowledge It's tr
by schoen 10y ago
I think this is a terminological suggestion from SpiderOak
https://spideroak.com/features/zero-knowledge https://spideroak.com/features/zero-knowledge
It's true that it doesn't match the technical meaning of zero knowledge from cryptography (although maybe arguably the meaning of the technical term could be extended to this situation in a trivial way: rather than a proof or protocol involving Bob from which Bob doesn't learn certain information, this is a protocol not involving Bob from which Bob also doesn't learn certain information).
- CiPHPerCoder 10y agoCounter argument: https://paragonie.com/blog/2016/08/crypto-misnomers-zero-knowledge-considered-self-descriptive https://paragonie.com/blog/2016/08/crypto-misnomers-zero-kno... Summary: zero-knowledge applies to authentication protocols, not encryption protocols.
- schoen 10y agoI think I'm inclined to agree with that interpretation. I wish we had a clearer term for systems where you don't trust an intermediary with some kind of access. (We often say "end-to-end encrypted", but that's kind of weird for file storage or other data-at-rest situations.)
- CiPHPerCoder 10y ago> I wish we had a clearer term for systems where you don't trust an intermediary with some kind of access. We already have one or more of: - Confidential - End-to-end encrypted (contrasted with, but often in addition to, transport-layer encryption) - Privacy-preserving - Least authority (with respect to the service operator) - Peer-to-peer privacy I'm one degree of separation from several SpiderOak engineers and think highly of them overall. However, this choice of marketing copy is one point we vehemently disagree on.