4 ms·
If anything, my only sadness is that more of Google's dirty laundry wasn't aired. This illusion that Google search is winning because people prefer it and that
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
If anything, my only sadness is that more of Google's dirty laundry wasn't aired. This illusion that Google search is winning because people prefer it and that Google doesn't make money on Android are both claims I'm happy to see debunked. Google's anti-monopoly claims fundamentally hinge on concepts like these.
And if a lawyer did break the law by doing it, I say she belongs on the same high pedestal people put Snowden on.
- Natsu 10y agoThere's a big difference between revealing the details of illegal actions, which Snowden did, and revealing your opponent's private financial dealings which are not illegal. Would you also support this if someone posted the routing information at the bottom of your personal checks? I mean, it's an "open secret" that's on every check. So no harm can come from the world at large knowing it.... right?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoGoogle's actions are illegal though. It's not a government coverup, but Google is using misinformation as 'proof' they aren't guilty. It's also noteworthy that this court case first revealed to the public the Android MADA agreement, a secret contract which has been at the center of a large number of antitrust suits around the globe. Had it not been revealed, it's unlikely many government entities would've started to look into it.
- Natsu 10y agoOracle is able to disclose this to the court, just not to the world at large. So if what you say is true, the court (including appeals) is the proper place to raise that argument.
- jhall1468 10y ago> Google's actions are illegal though. Have anything besides anecdotal evidence of that? Paying a company to use your search isn't anti-competitive. Google has competitors that can make the same (or better) offers. Google didn't prevent that behavior (in the way Microsoft did with Windows) because they can't... there are already alternatives. Google is a monopoly, but it's not anti-competitive without actual evidence. And your personal opinion doesn't qualify.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoHow about the FTC's? Google had a paid shill in as the FTC Commissioner at the time (Joshua Wright), so the case was buried, but FTC staff investigated and recommended they go forward with a formal action. The EU is of course, already moving forward, as is a few other countries, who don't have Google employees working in their respective governments.
- aaasssd 10y agoThere was alternatives to Internet Explorer when Microsoft got hit with the monopoly lawsuit...
- kuschku 10y agoSure, you can get my routing information. In any modern country, you can’t use that to scam me out of money anyway. If you need an IBAN, I can give you that in a few minutes.
- SysArchitect 10y agoUnfortunately the US is not a modern country in that regard...
- LeifCarrotson 10y ago> This illusion that Google search is winning because people prefer it People preferring it and Apple or Mozilla asking Google to pay them to include the search bar are not exclusive. If consumers prefer Google, and Apple couldn't make enough money with their own search engine to compensate for the lost users, it would make sense for Apple to pay Google for the right to use their search bar. Sure, Google could theoretically make money by giving it to them for free, or even by paying them to include it (see Mozilla), but why not get paid twice? > and that Google doesn't make money on Android I don't think anyone seriously believes that Android doesn't make money. Why else would Google put so much money into it in the first place?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoIt's well understood, I think, that the biggest determiner of what search engine people use is the default one put in front of them. That's why Google's willing to spend a billion dollars to be that default. Google's claims to it's antimonopoly position often hinges on the claim that it's a 'natural' monopoly, created simply by the fact that they have the best product. It's unsurprising, then, that they're so angry that this lawyer revealed Google pays so much to ensure their dominance. Google has long held that Android is something like a charity project, to "ensure an open future for mobile" or something like that. You can still see signs of it in the terms of the "Open Handset Alliance", which is actually the group of manufacturers Google forbids from using open source Android, ironically. It's also commonly the defense for why Google isn't a monopoly here: It "gives Android away for free". In reality, Google collects billions in profit, and leaves all of the software patching and support burdens on manufacturers, who can barely turn a profit and are held to Google's increasingly controlling mandates over how Android must be distributed. (I'm sure many OEMs after this case are curious why they're getting such a raw deal on Android, which is another reason it's unsurprising Google is so angry at Oracle.)
- Grazester 10y agoWhose fault is it that manufacturers cant turn a profit? Is Google suppose to give a handout to them when it gives them the source code to Android? Google provides the patch for the software. It is up the manufacturers to get it to their phones. Google is being the responsible one here if you ask me. Its the manufacture not providing support for their product who is at fault here.
- Oletros 10y agoSome people is so predictable
- Retra 10y agoIs that a problem somehow?