8 ms·
So, then it’d also be legal if I stand near all schools, and photograph every child with a telezoom lens, follow each of them home, and then publish a website w
by kuschku 10y ago
So, then it’d also be legal if I stand near all schools, and photograph every child with a telezoom lens, follow each of them home, and then publish a website with photos of every child and where they live?
If they don’t want to be seen, they can just stop broadcasting their face and wear a burqa, right?
There is a huge difference between "publicly available in every case seperately" and "publicly indexable".
EDIT: Instead of downvoting, please leave a comment instead – do you disagree because you believe there’s a fundamental difference between gigahertz and terahertz light waves? Or is there another reason you disagree?
- DominikR 10y agoIt is different because this behaviour fits a well know pattern of a certain type of criminal. The child molester. There is no such established pattern where we can reasonably assume that a company collecting SSIDs will usually do this to act in a criminal way. By the way I didn't down vote you, but I think this is the "common sense" reason why people reject your position.
- kuschku 10y agoWell, but it applies to every other such case, too. You can't publicly index newspaper articles that are already decades old and irrelevant, you can't publicly index photos of buildings, you can't publicly index the names of people even. Every of these things requires written approval of everyone listed, be it StreetView, the application of the Right to be Forgotten, or collecting WiFi SSIDs. So the question is: why does everything require approval, except for SSIDs?
- grkvlt 10y agoDoes it? I didn't give written approval for the Google StreetView car to photography the front of my house. If I was to create a database of photographs of buildings, taken from a public location and indexed by street address, I don't believe I have to get permission, and the product could be released publicly, or even sold to estate agents or similar. I used to have to give the phone company written (or st least explicit) notice to opt out of their public index of numbers and names. So, it seems most things operate the same way as SSIDs, public information requires an opt-out to be available, not an opt-in.
- kuschku 10y agoWell, here Google had to run a media campaign and had to wait for people explicitly say yes or no to streetview, and the phone books have been opt-in for decades, since the market was liberalized and the Postmonopol ended with it being split into Deutsche Post DHL, Postbank and T-Online. At least for Germany Google could have stayed within of this single law. I don’t care if Google literally would enslave and rape US-Americans – they chose to vote for politics that allows that – but Google should at least stay within of German law in Germany.
- KirinDave 10y agoIt was never illegal. It has always been legal. Debates were around asking if people could change the law to make it retroactively illegal. Also: down voted again for emotionally manipulative and outright vile rhetoric. If Hacker News is a place for free speech and open debate, you casually turning every conversation you can to molestation, rape and violence is a violation of the social contract we all have to keep the tone civil, and hurts the goal of honest debate.
- kuschku 10y agoBut that's literally what I don't care about? Google cando whatever they want, no matter how crazy it would be, in the US, as long as they follow the laws Ivoted for where I live. I use that hyperbole to make it specifically clear that I would literally not care. I literally wouldn't care if they used Blackwater's army to level entire cities if the people chose to allow this by voting. It's literally the worst case scenario, and hundred times more, and I wouldn't care. But I do care about them following the laws I voted for where I live. And yes, it was already illegal. German law has a principle where an action being done once or twice is very different from the same being automatically done thousands of times. That includes collecting SSIDs, likely.
- KirinDave 10y ago> And yes, it was already illegal. Oh really. Fascinating. That seems to line up with the history. > I use that hyperbole to make it specifically clear that I would literally not care. I would like to make it clear I specifically don't care what your justification is for invoking that specter. It's at best utterly irrelevant and unneeded. At worst, it's threatening. Find a better way to express this and you won't get downvotes. It's on you to communicate yourself in a socially acceptable way. If you don't care about that, then accept the downvotes as salty fluid that waters the tree of your liberty.
- xapata 10y agoYes, that probably is a legal activity. However, someone could sue for a restraining order. After that, and possibly further lawsuits, that activity would become illegal for you. The possibilities of human behavior are infinite. We don't need to and can't enumerate all possible bad behaviors as illegal. Thus the civil court system. On the second thought, I think there's some law against publishing images of people without their consent in some circumstances. I'm not clear on exactly what is allowed, but I know that TV broadcasters post notices in places that they are filming.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Yes, that probably is a legal activity. However, someone could sue for a restraining order. A restraining order is issued for either actually illegal activity, or for activity whose legal status is in dispute, and which would irreparably negatively impact a party in the case in which it that status was in dispute, or for activity which might straddle the line of legality but which is related to a broader pattern of activity which was found to be illegal. Its not done for specifically legal activity. > The possibilities of human behavior are infinite. We don't need and can't enumerate all possible bad behaviors as illegal. Thus the civil court system. The civil court system is for addressing things which are illegal -- violations of the law -- but which are not violation of criminal law. The civil court system applies those things prohibited in civil law, it does not substitute for having laws to determine what is prohibited.
- grkvlt 10y agoNo, a restraining order is issued when someone is performing actions that, taken individually, are legal - recording a link between an SSID and a street address, knocking on an ex-girlfriends door to ask them to talk to you, photographing a child - but when carried out systematically, constitute a pattern of behaviour that is undesirable, and by virtue of the order becomes illegal. Sometimes the pattern itself is also illegal, if it falls under harassment or stalking laws. Generally restraining orders prevent you from doing things that are otherwise legal, such as being within 50m of some person, or within 300m of a particular place or type of place, or sending a message, e-mail or similar to someone.
- mikestew 10y agoOthers have explained it, but I downvoted without comment because, to paraphrase Jules in Pulp Fiction: "that's not only not in the same ballpark, it's not even the same fuckin' sport." I wouldn't know how to comment beyond that. (That, and your "think of the children" didn't help.)
- kuschku 10y agoThen assume I'm talking about photographing every building and putting a list of that online. Also illegal. Or putting video surveillance up in public spaces. Also illegal, even for the government. Or whatever. Collect the router mac and BSSID? Possibly justifiable. That's like making a map where phone numbers are, physically. But collecting the SSID? Looking at the wifi list, I see "Meier family WiFi" and "Meier WiFi upper floor: Finn & Jan" (that's their children, having both the room on the upper floor, and family protection filters enabled for that WiFi). I see WiFi names that are identifiable, somes that have a little poetry in them, others named as the favourite football club of their owners. That's creative work and PII.
- xapata 10y ago> Then assume I'm talking about photographing every building and putting a list of that online. Also illegal. How is that illegal? That's called a map.
- KirinDave 10y agoI down voted and left a comment. Appealing to child stalking as a way to emotionally charge your argument about radio reception is a disingenuous tactic for this conversation. What's more, people who actually work to promote and secure a safer environment for kids don't need people like you constantly exacerbating parental paranoia with a constant back chatter stranger danger. Please refrain from emotionally manipulative rhetoric.
- kuschku 10y agoThen assume I'm talking about taking a picture of every living room through the window whenever no one is there. Or anything else that's that personal. The point isn't about what is collected, but that this type of broad data collection exists in the first place. Let's recap: not eventhe government can do video surveillance of public places, streetview became opt in, the phone book is opt in. But Google collects SSIDs? Collecting only the router mac or BSSID might possibly be justifiable, because it's just a map of technical data, but collecting a string where people but creative works in, or names, or jokes? I've seen families where the WiFi for the first floor had another name than that for the ground floor — specifically, the names of their two children, whose room was on first floor. Collecting such PII can be problematic.
- KirinDave 10y ago> Then assume I'm talking about taking a picture of every living room through the window whenever no one is there. No. That's not my job to arbitrarily re-interpret what you said to give you a free pass for your disingenuous rhetoric. > Let's recap: not eventhe government can do video surveillance of public places, streetview became opt in, the phone book is opt in. The government CAN do video surveillance though. Both our governments do it. What varies is how its deployed and who has access. > Collecting only the router mac or BSSID might possibly be justifiable, because it's just a map of technical data, but collecting a string where people but creative works in, or names, or jokes? Look, responsibility has to be exercised in all forms of data collection. But it's also the case that the light that shines out of your house is subject to public interpretation. Standing nude in your window facing a crowded street CAN be illegal in both our countries, as could placing a sign that says threatening things to passerbys. The trigger conditions for this vary between our countries, but they exist in both cases. > Collecting such PII can be problematic. COLLECTING PII is seldom the problem. Storing it or promptly and thoroughly deleting it is the challenge. You might argue that you shouldn't have collected it in the first place, and maybe that's true. But given the modern world where we have a rapidly expanding frontier of data analytics, it's actually difficult for real (re: not rhetorical trashbag arguments on HackerNews) people. Often times it's not obvious what PII is until later. For example, there are people who claim that transactional data can be "anonymized". Do not believe these people; it is nearly impossible to anonymize transactional data. Even mixing users and attempting to delocalize vendor strings will not fix the problems.
- nerdponx 10y agoI don't understand the down votes here, this is a sound analogy to me. I wouldn't be surprised if there were in fact laws against this kind of public surveillance behavior in some jurisdictions in the United States.