3 ms·
> Generally you get put in jail for committing crimes. That is true for prisons, but not jails. There is a big difference. Most people in jails are awaiting
by sandworm101 10y ago
> Generally you get put in jail for committing crimes.
That is true for prisons, but not jails. There is a big difference. Most people in jails are awaiting trials/hearings or other procedures. They haven't been convicted. I'd say not convicted 'yet' but an increasing number are never convicted. That doesn't mean they are innocent. Some are, but they may also go to diversionary programs without convictions.
Many individuals are held in jails pending psychiatric evaluations, after which no charges are brought as no prosecutable crime has been committed. And there is a very small subset of persons, material witnesses, who are held in jails without any suggestion that they have committed any crime.
Children certainly don't see much of a difference between jail and prison, but that's the problem. We too casually jail people without actual convictions and pretend it's OK because they aren't being held as convicts. But the kids are impacted just the same.
- ravenstine 10y ago> We too casually jail people without actual convictions and pretend it's OK because they aren't being held as convicts. But the kids are impacted just the same. Is there a better alternative? And are you suggesting that a significant number of people are being held in jail indefinitely without convictions? I find that hard to believe. I'm not saying that it doesn't happen, but I don't know that it's as much of a problem as you seem to be framing it to be.
- sandworm101 10y agoGo to any US jail. A large number of persons are in a form of indefinite detention awaiting proceedings that are regularly and repeatedly delayed. A prisoner in a prison can mark his exit date on a calender. Someone awaiting trial in a jail has no such definitive answer. Some could be released, but cannot afford the fees necessary to get a bail bond. Those are a real problem, people who are safe to release but too poor to afford it. The only convicts in jails are those serving sentences of less than a year. Anything greater than that goes to a prison, give or take depending on circumstances. So yes, there is a very large population of persons in jails without convictions. That's what they are for. The answer is probably a better-resourced court system capable of processing hearings more efficiently. Remember the tv-series Night Court? Night courts were meant to accelerate the process of hearings and get people out on bail more quickly. They didn't handle trials. They have almost disappeared today.