3 ms·
Anti science? Offering an opinion on the potential shortcomings of a scientific theory isn't anti-science. Discussions of land bridges once touched on some ra
by sandworm101 10y ago
Anti science? Offering an opinion on the potential shortcomings of a scientific theory isn't anti-science. Discussions of land bridges once touched on some rather dark assumptions regarding the abilities of past peoples, specifically outdated notions that "primitive" cultures could not travel oceans. It is very scientific to hold them to standards based on what we now know about these cultures. Thor Heyerdahl was not "anti-science" when his work challenged land bridge assumptions.
It doesn't matter what evidence this theory is backed by. What matters is the sum total of all available evidences, especially outside evidence not addressed initially. I do not subscribe to this theory because it does not address several pieces of available evidence that other theories better address. What is anti-science is the blind acceptance of theories that are at best internally consistent.
- ethagknight 10y ago(Not a historian and only skimmed the article for reasons below): I take these sorts of presentations of data with a grain of salt when the article says something to the effect of "our old, sweeping theory that we presented as reliable history was wrong, so here is a new sweeping theory based on a couple new findings which we will now present as reliable history." So I quit reading as closely. I might prefer a more clear delineation of what is evidence and what is speculation. Interesting nonetheless.