3 ms·
>> "fair game"? "Fair game" excuses collective punishment, then? I'm not so sure. Also, a "wife" is a person. How do you justify retaliating against someone b
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
>> "fair game"?
"Fair game" excuses collective punishment, then? I'm not so sure.
Also, a "wife" is a person. How do you justify retaliating against someone by harming someone else? You steal my car, I beat up your wife- hey, "fair game"?
- Nexxxeh 10y ago(Not parent poster but...) No, but you steal his car, you can't complain if he steals yours. I don't think Krebs was right to dox the hackers wife. She's her own person. If being married to an asshat is a punishable crime then many people are even worse off than they realise. But Krebs retaliated in kind. I do however think that's a punch he should have pulled.
- radley 10y agoIs the wife in any actual danger from his reveal? I imagine Krebs thought no and that's the difference.
- justavoice 10y agoPretty simple, you up the stakes until the person attacking you stops. You never watched ScarFace?
- digler999 10y agoIt might destroy their relationship by scaring her into leaving him, which is perfectly fair game. You dont deserve to have a relationship with your wife if you actively try to destroy someone else's.
- intrasight 10y agoIs the strongest argument - but still too weak.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> It might destroy their relationship by scaring her into leaving him, which is perfectly fair game. So, should Krebs have flown over to Russia and beat the shit out of her? That would have definitely "scared her into leaving" the guy. Again: how is it "fair game" to punish one person for the actions of another?
- AJ007 10y agoRelatives of a victim are generally protected by the press, but relatives of a criminal are not. Right or wrong this doesn't seem outside of accepted USA norms. Other countries are another matter, where often criminals identities are protected.
- PavlovsCat 10y ago> Right or wrong this doesn't seem outside of accepted USA norms. Yeah, but the question is about right and wrong, not accepted USA norms.
- woodpanel 10y agoI put it in quotes because I have a hard time considering it "fair" myself. The main point here is: this anti-social behaviour of the Hacker was made possible because of his anonymity. Anonymous towards the legal system but anonymous towards his private life as well. It is fair to assume he kept his cyberbullying activities to himself because she wouldn't support that. The hacker's wife was probably more endangered by continuing to be living next to a criminal.