4 ms·
Likely. Intelligence is molded by the container. Much of our self is shaped by being mammals, with two eyes and two ears and limited perception of the world. A
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
Likely. Intelligence is molded by the container. Much of our self is shaped by being mammals, with two eyes and two ears and limited perception of the world.
An artificial creature could be completely different from that. It will perceive the world in a different light, literally. It will need different language to describe what it experiences, and we will have only indirect referents to appreciate what its talking about.
E.g. an intelligent drone might want to express what it felt when hovering at 5000 ft over Manhattan in a slight crosswind during a cell tower outage - the EM spectrum image shifts in such an utterly sublime way when your sensors are vibrating and the low band is uncluttered!
- sillysaurus3 10y agoSee also: the paperclip maximizer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_convergence#Paperclip_maximizer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_convergence#Paper... I like it because it illustrates the idea that digital AI probably won't be like us. Earth's animals are similar thanks to evolution on Earth. We have a fear of dying, a need to reproduce, and an inability to prevent genetic diversity. What will happen when these constraints are removed?
- jupiter90000 10y agoI totally agree with this. A significant part of what shapes human perception of reality is not just 'nature' but 'nurture'. How would we be able to fully re-create all the social creation of a version of collective reality that a human experiences due to being indoctrinated for years by parents, family, friends, the community, and society? I doubt this is something that could be trivially re-created by scientists in a lab-setting, much less fiddling with algorithms. It seems once the basis for human-like learning was in place for a machine, to approach human-like 'intelligence' the machine would need the appropriate social environment to learn the socially appropriate symbols and constructs to effectively relate to the world and function in a given community and society. This assumes we care about having human-like intelligence. If not, it perhaps won't apply.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoThere's a very interesting question of if we can have a human-communicating, non-human intelligence. It's likely that our first AI will be something like that: a mind which is internally very unlike our own, but which has a substantial fraction devoted to being able to explain the human understandable versions of its thoughts. The scary part is that to us, it likely will feel very human, but to it, we'll likely be nothing but steering ants by laying out sugar.
- freyr 10y ago> Much of our self is shaped by being mammals, with two eyes and two ears and limited perception of the world. Of course we've built visible light cameras and microphones, which mimic our own sensory inputs. Machines will likely have these same sensors. They can have additional sensors (IR, radar, etc.), or not. That's up to us. Touch, taste, smell, and physical sensations of pain and pleasure are not yet modeled in machines, but presumably this would be possible. Human intelligence is molded by hundreds of thousands of years of evolutionary pressure to hunt, procreate, attack other tribes, avoid being eaten, avoid being cast out of the community, etc. Our emotions are likely closely tied to these functions. It's not clear that machines can or should be designed according to these same environmental pressures.