4 ms·
> The whole point of finance is maximizing profits; I think that people need to understand and accept this for us to have a meaningful discussion. Former finan
by wpietri 10y ago
> The whole point of finance is maximizing profits; I think that people need to understand and accept this for us to have a meaningful discussion.
Former finance person here. I understand but don't accept. The individual's point may be maximizing profits. The societal point of what we reward, permit, hinder, or ban? That is definitely not maximizing profits.
One way to look at it is to compare it with video games. An individual player's proximate goal might be to maximize points scored. But the game designer's goal is broader. The society's goal is broader still. One could even look at the evolutionary purpose of play itself.
For those interested in this sort of distinction, I strongly recommend James Carse's "Finite and Infinite Games": https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004W3FM4A/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004W3FM4A/
- jacquesm 10y agoA game designers goal is (most of the time) to maximize his own profits.
- simonh 10y agoBut society's goal of maximizing the benefit (profit) to society from the Finance industry is not the same as a Finance company's goal of maximizing profit for themselves. In both cases the goals are complimentary in some ways but conflict in others and one is purely monetary while the other might be progress towards many different societal goals.
- gaius 10y agoBut society's goal of maximizing the benefit (profit) to society from the Finance industry is not the same as a Finance company's goal of maximizing profit for themselves. Well it is if you tax those profits, obv closing loopholes. Societies work when all the participants interests are aligned. If farmers can get rich growing crops, there will never be a famine.
- coriny 10y ago> If farmers can get rich growing crops, there will never be a famine. You're not considering that food has a limited shelf life, seasonal, difficult to distribute efficiently and the customers have highly variable purchasing powers. Also local production is incredibly sensitive to local environmental variation. We already produce enough food to feed nearly twice the global population, and yet plenty of people are malnourished. I would personally suggest that the best way to prevent famines is to improve food storage and distribution methods, and have robust systems for environmental or conflict induced local famines. Though the unbalanced nature of consumer wealth is also important - it makes sense to waste 50% of your crop selling it in Europe if you can sell it for 3x as much than locally. So maybe the best thing is simply to raise the wealth of poorest people in the world?
- gaius 10y agoI think perhaps you are missing the wider point I am making :-)
- coriny 10y agoI'm not sure, I kind of disagreed with both statements you were making, and decided to pick holes in the latter, since it was providing support for the former. If I'm missing a "wider point", can you elucidate?
- gaius 10y agoYou disagree that societies work best when the interests of all the participants are aligned? This seems obvious to me, so I am curious as to what you object to. If people are rewarded for doing thing X, X will be more likely to happen, and if they are punished for Y, then Y will be less likely to happen. Clearly there will be outliers, but why would you construct a society that actively penalises things that it wants?
- michaelt 10y ago
- rfrey 10y agowpietri's point was that the player's primary goal was different than the game designer's goal, just as the individual trader's goal might be different than society's goals in setting up the trading arena.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIn the indie world you can tell if that was the goal by looking at how crappy the game is. It works in general too - if there's a difference in quality when people focus on the thing they're making vs. money it's supposed to bring in.
- kakarot 10y agoI would rather make a game a million people play for free than making a game that nets a million that only one person plays
- wpietri 10y agoI guess we must know pretty different game designers. That's definitely not what the ones I know focus on.