5 ms·
The problem is that if an auto-injector is truly needed (onset of anaphylaxis), there may not be much time to futz around with it, if it doesn't work properly.
by snowwrestler 10y ago
The problem is that if an auto-injector is truly needed (onset of anaphylaxis), there may not be much time to futz around with it, if it doesn't work properly.
The auto-injector apparatus is not regulated because it is dangerous; it is regulated because a failure to operate would be dangerous. It is regulated for reliability.
The hacker/maker ethos is awesome and drives a lot of innovation in our society, but sometimes there is also a need for careful engineering and rigorous testing.
- BurningFrog 10y agoRight, but something 90% effective that you can afford will save a lot more lives than the 100% effective version you can't.
- abraae 10y agoWell put. I've got a heart issue going on and I've had some fascinating results from capturing my heart rate on a consumer grade chest band monitor, then uploading it to influxdb and viewing it with grafana. Total outlay a couple of hundred bucks. Invaluable to me in tracking what's going on with my heart. Yet that whole stack would never be approved by... Anyone!
- gravypod 10y agoYou should open source it. Would be cool to see how you're doing data vis for this.
- balls187 10y ago> Right, but something 90% effective that you can afford will save a lot more lives than the 100% effective version you can't. What is the cross section of america can carefully construct a DYI Epi-Pen, but can't afford the actual Epi-Pen?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI guess it may be large. Many people have more discretionary free time than money. I surely had when I was a student; I could afford the $50 DIY contraption and assemble it myself, but no way in hell I could find a spare $300.
- snowwrestler 10y agoYou pulled 90% out of the air, though. What if it's 42%? If you think 90% is a better target than 100% for overall public health, well, fine, that's a classic kind of public health policy argument. But without a regulatory system of some kind, you won't know what the actual number is for a given product. EDIT to add: I'm not arguing that DIY auto-injectors should be illegal to build in general. I'm in favor of people having the freedom to experiment with their own care if they want to. I am arguing that DIY is not an adequate substitute for the general public unless the actual risks are well understood.
- BurningFrog 10y agoI doubt anyone thinks this is an adequate systemic solution. I'm just saying it's better than nothing. Think of it as the best that can be achieved within a broken and unchangeable system.
- snowwrestler 10y agoSo folks know, there are already at least 2 EpiPen alternatives that are FDA approved. One is the "Adrenaclick," which is another epinephrine autoinjector that (and this is key) must be specifically prescribed. You can't take an EpiPen prescription and ask for an Adrenaclick, your doctor has to specifically prescribe Adrenaclick. But right now it's a lot cheaper. A friend just switched and his copay went from $200 for EpiPen to $8 for Adrenaclick. The other is to buy a bottle of epinephrine and use syringes, or buy pre-filled epinephrine syringes. Again, a doctor must specifically prescribe this, but it's a lot cheaper than EpiPen. More complicated to self-administer in an emergency, though--but better than nothing, especially for 3rd parties with access to training, like wilderness guides, teachers, etc.
- BurningFrog 10y agoThe pre-filled syringes are not FDA approved, according to http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/08/29/reverse-voxsplaining-drugs-vs-chairs/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/08/29/reverse-voxsplaining-dr... (search for Adamis)
- astazangasta 10y agoCareful engineering and rigorous testing does not require FDA approval. Hackers and makers can do their own rigorous testing and publish their methodology, which can be scrutinized by peer review. What's unlikely is that a DIY production scheme can ensure consistent manufacturing quality, since the careful, rigorous hackers are not going to be making this for everyone.
- throwaway34803 10y agoBased on the implementation of regulation in the US, I'd say the purpose of regulation is clear: To make a monopoly / oligopoly on drugs. > It is regulated for reliability. Then why aren't the tests and methods of testing reliability required to be published? > it is regulated because a failure to operate would be dangerous The risk of not having it at all far outweighs the risk of the injector failing. Not to mention that regulated injectors fail too due to manufacturing defects. > sometimes there is also a need for careful engineering and rigorous testing. But should that need preclude private individuals from assembling their own life saving devices on a small scale (1-10 units)? We're not talking about someone else stealing your design, process, research, and building their own production line here. Furthermore, careful engineering and rigorous testing is needed when you're creating a production line of these things. A competent individual can assess and test their own device. Yes, it's more time consuming, but for something as essential as a life saving drug, it's probably worth the extra time.