4 ms·
I'd venture that at that scale you don't really have much of an option except going active. Passive is essentially swimming with the stream, but what if you're
by Havoc 10y ago
I'd venture that at that scale you don't really have much of an option except going active. Passive is essentially swimming with the stream, but what if you're big enough to affect the stream...you're kinda active in a way already right there.
- tim333 10y agoYeah but I'd pick stocks for them for a thousandth of that.
- Cyph0n 10y agoThat's why you're not picking stocks for them ;)
- 010a 10y agoThe difference between $60k and $60M, for a fund nearly a trillion dollars large, is worth it if that person worth $60M can eek out even a few extra basis points in returns. Despite what many people believe, there are those out there who have an eye for value, and _can_ pick stocks.
- jellicle 10y ago> there are those out there who have an eye for value, and _can_ pick stocks. There's simply no evidence that is true at all. Every study of this issue says the exact opposite: there's no one out there who can pick stocks.
- lemiant 10y agoIn general I've always agreed with this view. But I can't help but wonder how studies like this explain Berkshire Berkshire Hathaway.
- xyzzy123 10y agoWhich is funny because BH have literally the opposite bet: http://longbets.org/362/ http://longbets.org/362/ It seems a bit contradictory, but BH is a holding company versus a hedge fund.
- cheriot 10y agoIt's not that contradictory. As long as the market for stock pickers overcharges, people can be good at it and a bad deal at the same time.
- xyzzy123 10y agoRight but if you follow the theory if you had alpha greater than fees then you could essentially control all funds available for management (up to the scale where your atrategies stop working). Which is sort of its own reductio ab absurdum.
- shardinator 10y agoNot sure if this is what you're asking, but if fund returns are random but different, then someone is going to have the best performing fund. Let's say the best performing fund is (fictional) Xanadu Investments we'd ask, how do we explain Xanadu's performance.
- jellicle 10y agoBerkshire seems to be good at buying and managing companies in order to make money. But not so good at just buying stock: http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/berkshire-hathaway-stock-warren-buffett/ http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/berkshire-hathaway-stock-warre...
- 10y ago
- olalonde 10y ago> is worth it if that person worth $60M can eek out even a few extra basis points in returns [...] and no one else could/would have performed better for less than $60M.
- tomp 10y agoThat's not the point. The way compensation works, usually, is that you say, "if you do well, we'll pay you this much", where "this much" depends on how well the person does. You can't change your mind post-fact, "well, anyone could have done this well, so we won't actually pay you this much".
- kristofferR 10y agoThe funny thing is that in this case they actually somehow managed to pay him half of what he was entitled to according to their agreement.
- olalonde 10y agoI don't doubt that they were contractually bound to pay the 60M$. The parent comment sort of implied that the fund couldn't possibly have overpaid, because 60M$ is such a small fraction of profits. All I'm saying is that they might have overpaid, at the time of signing the contract, if another equally skilled manager would have taken the job for a smaller compensation package.
- jhj 10y agoEh, the money is going in and eventually coming out over lengthy timescales. If active management means dipping into a smaller number of tradable assets, then the effect would only be worse. If they have to split it between a large number of active managers with different strategies because their fund is too big, then they might be de facto indexing the broader market while paying over the odds for it. For assets traded on an exchange at least (e.g., not directly-invested real estate), it's more of a logistical problem than anything else: how do you track indices that you want to track by dripping money into and out of the market, both trying not to affect supply/demand too much, but while not deviating from the index too much. It's the same problem that a BlackRock or Vanguard face but at slightly smaller (!) scale, and one more for computer programmers with knowledge of market microstructure than people that demand outsize bonuses who think they have "alpha" and get lucky (or not).
- MarkMc 10y agoThey are still only 1% of global stocks - hardly 'big enough to affect the stream'
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoIt's nearly a trillion dollars. Yes, a trillion dollars is market-making. If it all moved at once world economies would shit themselves for a time. Even beyond that, there are only about 200 sovereign states in the world. I'd say a country like Norway, with fewer citizens than the state of Washington, controlling 1% of global anything is noteworthy and undeserving of scoff.